Lorelei Restaurant Cabana Bar - Feedback

The restaurant was closed, yet there was a group of people inside drinking. As we approached, a woman yelled, “We are closed, come back tomorrow.” We just wante...

I went there for dinner around 6 PM, but it was more of a drinking spot than a dining one. I never felt so unwelcome in a restaurant before, so we decided to le...

The location is fantastic, but the food and service were just mediocre. The new mermaid sign feels out of place—I'd prefer to see the old one return.

Amazing food, service, and scenery. Doesn’t get better than that!! My fiancé and I had the conch fritters, crab chowder, mahi tacos and snapper sandwich. I reco...

Coming here for 30 years! You catch and they will cook it ..... blackened, grilled or fried!

Sitting for dinner on Sunday night, but could not sit for a while. Came back to lunch on a boat of Robbie rented and LOVED it much more than expected! The food...

Open water!!!! This place deceives. There is a TON of large seats on the water. In a position to get a place right next to the water. Server was excellent and f...

Lorelei is definitely a restaurant we will be visiting again, on the answering machine they advised getting there by 4:30 in the winter season, just to make sur...

What a look! Food was not the best, but in any case to check, restaurant is right on the water! We saw sister sharks, jellyfish and many other fish right from o...

The restaurant offers stunning sunset views. The service was excellent, although we had to wait a bit to be seated after arriving early in the evening. The drin...

This wonderful spot offers amazing breakfast, lunch, dinner, and cocktails, all in a charming rustic setting by the water. You can enjoy your meal at the bar, a...

We visit Lorelei every time we go to the Keys! This time, we had a friendly and nice server who was incredibly efficient and attentive. The conch we had was fan...

The ambiance is stunning, the food is fantastic, and the service is excellent. They serve the most amazing Key Lime Coladas I've ever tasted! I truly did not wa...

Best Key Lime coladas conch fritters!! A must stop on your way down to back from) Key West!

Went today for lunch. What an awesome view!! Our waitress could not have done a better job. The food was not only delicious, the prices were very...

Nice tourist place. Great place to view an amazing sunset. Food is typical bar style food. Service is nice but a little slow but maybe that's done on purpose to...

While staying on Islamorada for a few days, we really lucked out with a perfect table at Lorelei for some afternoon drinks. Their unique bar area right over the...

Went here hoping their dinner was as good as their breakfast. It wasn 't! Not good at all. The only thing they have going for them is the location. Fries were c...

Great spot. Good food. Been many times. Could be a little cleaner and broken fans replaced. My only negative comment is Rob the manager appears to be an a$$hole...

As we were driving down to Key West, we had to stop for a Bushwacker and water view. Lorelei's is the place. It is a quaint place with a variety of seating and...

This restaurant offers an exceptional dining experience across the board. With prices ranging from $10 to $20 per person, it provides fantastic value. The food...

Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Seafood Tacos, Conch Fritters Parking: Plenty of space available, with free parking options.

The atmosphere was fantastic, and the restaurant has a lovely setting. However, our waitress appeared to be quite unsteady on her feet. She nearly tripped and s...

Price per person: $20–30 Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Great breakfast...