Images
Contribute
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Rickey Wilson likes about Xtrordinary Pizza:
Ordered with everything except mushroom and jalapeños. This pizza weighs all of 5 pounds, there in my opinion is nothing better than ground sausage. The only issue is the crust is a bit soggy due to the grease. Over all it is a great pizza. Can’t wait to try the calzone. View all feedback.
What Andy Shank doesn't like about Xtrordinary Pizza:
Don?t sleep on Xtrordinary! I live on the other side of town so when I was visiting family and offered to bring pizza, of course google wanted me to go to the Ordinary. But there was some crazy parade going on which made it impossible to get to. Luckily that led me to Xtrordinary. It?s hard to see from the road but it?s back there. Service was great and you have to lovethe ?no toppings or all the toppings? same price... View all feedback.
Absolutely Best Pizza in Indianapolis ???? I eat it for breakfast, lunch and dinner when I order it! Great Job Pizza ???? Xtrordinary's???????????????????????
Literally the best pizza in the city. And I love their hours. I'm not a breakfast food type of person. So I enjoy that I can go get a fresh pizza at 10am. Highly recommend
We had a fantastic experience at this restaurant! While passing through the area, we looked up food options and decided to give it a try. Please note that they do not have indoor dining, but we placed our order at the counter and waited in our car. They called out our name on a speaker when our food was ready. We ordered two personal pizzas, and we absolutely loved them! In fact, I was able to turn one pizza into two meals. There were plenty of delicious toppings, and the breadsticks were amazing! The wait time was minimal, and we would definitely return.
I ordered delivery from this restaurant and let me tell you, the pizza is outstanding! It's the best I've had since my last trip to Chicago and Gino's Pizza. One slice had me feeling completely full! The staff was very friendly, and the delivery was incredibly quick. I’ll definitely order from here again when I'm in the area.
Don't overlook Xtrordinary! I live on the other side of town, and when I was visiting family and offered to bring pizza, Google directed me to The Ordinary. However, due to a hectic parade blocking the way, I ended up discovering Xtrordinary. It's a bit hidden from the road, but it's definitely worth the hunt. The service was fantastic, and I loved their unique pricing model of "no toppings or all the toppings" for the same price. The pizza was packed with delicious toppings and absolutely fantastic. Give this place a try and don’t be an Ordinary follower like I almost was!
More information
QR-code link to the menu
