Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Polly's Pies:
How did I forget about Polly for so many years? I visited this place when I was in kindergarten, and I swear it hasn’t changed one bit since then. In this case, that's actually a great thing. The food is fantastic, with generous portion sizes, reasonable prices, and an amazing variety of flavors. The service is excellent, and we truly connected with some of the staff. Don't overlook this gem from your past—it's defin... View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Polly's Pies:
This is hands down the worst dining experience I’ve ever had. I’ve been a long-time customer at Polly’s, but the quality of their pies has continued to decline over the years, along with their customer service. Our food was undercooked, and when we requested it to be cooked further, the kitchen staff reacted as if we were in the wrong, even making a point to walk across the restaurant loudly to announce that our panc... View all feedback.
Just your average diner. The burger was really good, but the fries were just average. The burger combo comes with a slice of pie ?.Food: 3/5
Been coming here for many many years. Food and service is great. Nice having bakery goods available and they are good.Food: 5/5
Amazing breakfast and pie spot. Home potatoes are great, eggs are cooked exactly how you order them, and the link sausages has casings on them. You can add a giant cinnamon roll for less than a dollar extra Fantastic all around.Food: 5/5
It was meh. The bacon tasted, off, like it had absorbed flavors from the grill or other grease perhaps? The egg and breakfast potatoes were cooked well. The toast appeared like it had been heated but arrived to our table late and cold. We will pass on Polly's for breakfast next time, but will always pop in for some pie!!! The pie is great!
My wife and I rediscovered this Polly 's after many years of not going there. Older wait staff has been replaced with younger ladies who are very friendly and efficient. The menu is new and seems to be quite well thought out as well as extensive. The only downside to the place is the temperature is set extremely low, possibly around 65 degrees, and the background music, if you can call it that, is to loud. Not very comfortable for anyone while trying to enjoy a hot relaxing meal. Better wear a coat or sweater and hope you like the music too.
More information
QR-code link to the menu
