Sweet Melissa's - Feedback

What Britany Nathan Sizemore doesn't like about Sweet Melissa's:
Mashed potatoes are instant, which I don't even eat in my own home. If I am going to pay to eat somewhere I expect something better or at least half as good as what I would make myself. Also, the coleman's fish basket is a dollar more than the sandwich, served on a plate, and is the same piece of fish as the sandwich, just minus the bread and lettuce. They also serve your coleslaw in a tiny ketchup cup. On a positive... View all feedback. What Dennis Bills likes about Sweet Melissa's:
Best pies within a 50 mile radius. Definitely worth the trip. My wife and I drove all the way in from New Martinsville just to have a couple of slices. I had the vanilla walnut and my wife had a slice of the pecan caramel pie. Of course we shared. Good value, and the slices were big enough to take some home with us. The diner is quaint with a full menu, and we met the owners, who were super nice. I think the Double V... View all feedback.