Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about Rosalie Italian Soul:
Checked in to The Baldwin on Valentine's weekend and wanted dinner but no reservations (highly suggest checking on that first! . The hostesses said we could get in if we could eat and leave in an hour...by 6:20! The restaurant decorations are interesting and fun, not your typical Italian look. We had the meatball appetizer (not as good as everyone made them out to be but ok. They didn't serve any bread or light snack... View all feedback.
What Jessica Betschart doesn't like about Rosalie Italian Soul:
Restaurant and hotel are cute and decorated well but food and service was terrible. Multiple things went wrong during our dinner. Slow service, 1 person's dish was not made, server did not know the menu or products at all. Would not recommend. View all feedback.
We loved the vibe of the restaurant eclectic, not cluttered, comfortable seating. Perfect place for a date. It took a while (over 5 minutes) for a server to greet us at our table but when he did show up, he was friendly and the service was great. The meatballs (2) served with grilled sourdough bread were a perfect starter to share. The manicotti was excellent (unexpectedly and delightfully spicy) and I shared it with my husband. He ordered the ravioli (pistachio cream) and while it was delicious, it was a skimpy portion, more appropriate for an appetizer than the main dish. Overall, we will likely recommend to friends and will stop by again when on the way to a show in the Theater District.
Jake and the pizza was amazing! We are looking forward to coming back!
Mediocre pizza. I ordered meat lovers and the ham on top was cold, rolled deli ham??? Sausage nearly non existent. Ingredients generally disappointing but the dough was soft and tasty. Negroni was over bittered. Oh yeah, and the valet dudes were weird.
Service and ambiance was great! Food was good but nothing special. Definitely not a bad option if you're staying at the hotel or in the area!
Restaurant and hotel are cute and decorated well but food and service was terrible. Multiple things went wrong during our dinner. Slow service, 1 person's dish was not made, server did not know the menu or products at all. Would not recommend.