Otie's Tavern Grill - Hilliard

Hummus was spicy and not good. Philly sandwich was very greasy and fries almost burned. Nachos were good though. The patio is beautiful, but food just ok. Probably not coming back. It took a while to get service and food, as normal to all places right now.

I’ve ordered the pub burger twice and the plates were very different both times… first time was amazing and the last time was disgusting… one time it came with the egg over medium and the last time was over hard. The first time it’s had normal burger condiments and the last time it came with this brown stuff, do not eat the brown stuff! Both times I went there they were out of ginger beer to make Moscow mules and “it’s supposed to be delivered later today” both times I went there… kinda sus… the place is hit or miss, no consistency.

My friend and I decided to try this restaurant for the first time. We sat outside on the patio, which is breathtaking! Our waiter was not attentive at all! We ordered the nachos as an appetizer and they were delicious. I ordered the Reuben and fries. The fries were bland. My sandwich was delicious, but they barely put any 1000 Island on it and when I asked for more, I was charged, which I didn’t realize until I got the bill. My friend got a hamburger which barely had any mayonnaise on it. By the time the waiter came back so we could ask for more, it was cold. We asked for extra napkins and we were given 1 each. Service was really bad. I asked to speak to a manager, but was told that our waiter was the closest thing to a manager. He was not friendly and barely checked on us. I needed a refill before we left and he never offered one. Very disappointed!

Summer Pattio and roof bar are great. Have a good look at Hilliard events on the street also in summer. Love the old world pizza, roasted green beans and a gyro, but had nothing bad there. Beer selection is quite standard to choose with a few craftsmen.

We were greeted immediately after walking into the door and asked to sit somewhere we liked. We had the whole area for us, as everyone else decided to sit outside. It took a few minutes until the waitress came by, but after that it was very efficient. The decor was mainly historical photos mixed with some sports paraphers. The outdoor terrace was absolutely beautiful. Our food came fast and it was as amazing as the waitress said it was. I had the Barburger and Pommes. A beautiful burger with mozzarella, provolone and cheddar cheese and bacon and a fried egg with salad, tomatoes and onions. My partner had her signature sandwich from fried Bologna. Thickly cut Bologna with pepper jack cheese, pickles and onions. The frits were a thicker natural cut, made to a crispy and covered with coarse salt. The best pommes I had in a while. If we go back to Hilliard at any time, we'll stop.