Bay Ave Bakery And Cafe - HIGHLANDS

I ordered a ham and Swiss cheese sandwich on rye today, and it was the worst sandwich I've ever had. The bread was stale, and the ham was overly thick and slimy. I've been a customer there for more than 20 years, and I'm extremely disappointed with my experience.

The sandwiches and pastries are excellent. It's a lovely bike ride from the Sandy Hook lighthouse!

I ordered a pork roll, egg, and cheese on a bagel for $7.xx, and with a small coffee, my total came to $10.13. It did upset my stomach a bit, but I’m not sure if it was the coffee or the sandwich. They have a great selection of baked goods that look tempting and might be worth a try. The prices are a bit higher, but that's becoming the norm everywhere. I’ve posted some photos so you can judge for yourself!

Holy cow I had the best cookie ever!! Seriously good baked goods here

Best bakery around!!! From cakes, to cookies, to brownies, crumb cakes so tasty!!! Don’t forget the cafe that also has good sandwiches and small area for eat in breakfast lunch !!