Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What James McInerney likes about Bagel Boss Hicksville:
Excellent bagels and they are open 24hrs which is a big plus. A must try is the rainbow cookie cake. It is easily one of the best rainbow cookies that I have ever had. Visit 2sweetheartsreview on Instagram for more reviews. View all feedback.
What Raphael Dembinski doesn't like about Bagel Boss Hicksville:
$35/lb for baked salmon salad? THIRTY. FIVE. A. POUND. LOL! I can get Alaskan King Crab legs for cheaper than that. Yea, I can literally have someone get on a boat in frigid cold rough dangerous seas thousands of miles away, pulling crabs off the ocean floor and ship them to me boiled and cleaned for cheaper than Bagel Boss baking some farmed salmon and mashing it up with mayo like it's potatoes.
Always come here to place my order for my brother that lives in Georgia. Thank you, Terry for always helping me. My #1 stop before my road trip. And to the young man that gave me my bags told me how to keep it fresh till I get to Georgia.
The best! A must stop when we visit our families in NY. Until next time!
Some of the best bagels on the planet! So many other treats too! Truly a Long Island classic! Outstanding service!
I just stopped in for a cup of coffee, first visit. Counter service was very good, 4 people very helpful, you feel like a served customer instead of customer service. Hazlet coffee was in a canteen outside the counter, still hot and fresh.
$35 per pound for baked salmon salad? THIRTY. FIVE. DOLLARS. A. POUND. Seriously? I can buy Alaskan King Crab legs for less than that! I could actually have someone brave the icy, perilous seas thousands of miles away to catch crabs, and have them shipped to me, boiled and cleaned, for a better price than what Bagel Boss is charging for some farmed salmon mixed with mayo. It's like they're making mashed potatoes or something!
More information
QR-code link to the menu
