What If Of Hershey

American, Italian, Coffee
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +17175335858
Reservation
Reservation request for What If Of Hershey.

Menu

The restaurant from Hershey offers 140 different menus and drinks on the menu for an average price of $13.3.

The What If... of Hershey, is located in the sweetest place on earth, Hershey, Pennsylvania. Descend the warmly lit steps to our bar and enjoy our famous house-infused martinis made with fresh squeezed juice. Our eclectic menu features bountiful crab martinis, beef or seafood sliders, and signature dishes like pan-seared scallops and fresh calamari, or chicken saltimbocca and hand-cut filets. Indulge in sweet endings with our on-premise made treats, including Hershey's favorite Hot Fudge Peanut Profiterole. Come experience innovative drinks, eclectic food, and genuine Hershey hospitality at our avenue location.

Last update: 11.12.2025

Images

What If Of Hershey food What If Of Hershey food What If Of Hershey food What If Of Hershey food

Reservation request for What If Of Hershey

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 5456 reviews

What If in Hershey, PA offers a mix of dining experiences, with some diners enjoying the excellent food and service, while others found the value for money, portion sizes, and noise level to be less than ideal. Some reviewers were impressed with the high-quality dishes, professional service, and warm ambiance, making it a great spot for special occasions like Valentine's Day. Despite some hiccups with overcooked steaks and slow service, many diners raved about the outstanding desserts and overall positive experience. Whether you're looking for a cozy date night setting or a place to enjoy a tasty meal with friends, What If offers a diverse dining experience worth checking out.

jellyfishart
jellyfishart 28.10.2024 - 05:36

The crab cakes are divine. My favorite place to get crab cakes. We also had the cobble for dessert. It was delicious! :

carol
Carol 28.10.2024 - 05:36

Food and service were excellent as always...consistently delicious food and cocktails...you can always rely on What If for a great meal and awesome service!

glennb
Glennb 28.10.2024 - 05:36

Food was excellent and service was good. Noise was very loud. Also when i made the reservation i put down we were celebrating a birthday and nothing was every mentioned. Other then that excellent.

catherinel
CatherineL 28.10.2024 - 05:36

The food and service were excellent. We always enjoy going to What If.

quincy-65
Quincy 08.03.2020 - 10:12

The crab cakes are divine. my favorite place to get crabcake. we also had the cobble for dessert. it was delicious!

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.