Sal's Pizzeria Of Cooperstown

Ordered 12 pizzas to pickup. They said they could do it. Went to pickup and was ignored by two staff members. Literally just kept blowing me off. They could have just said they couldn’t do it. Instead I went to another pizza shop who completed my order in 30 minutes and was $90/cheaper. Sal’s was unorganized, unprofessional, and I’ll never know but their food probably follows suit. Go somewhere else.

We were in town for a baseball tournament and a week before arriving one of the team mom’s called and reserved tables for us for 7/26. Lady on the phone said we’re all set but them we arrive and they claim they had no idea we were coming. Thanks for screwing up an afternoon that was supposed to be a great team outing.

Pizza was just okay. The service wasn’t very good and it took forever to get just 2 slices of pizza.

We stopped in after the Parade of Legends. The place was mobbed. Minerva, our waitress, was an absolute doll through it all! She greeted everyone with a smile and had such an upbeat attitude. Her husband was a sweetheart too!! He was helping out and had a smile on his face the whole time. Their pizza is excellent!! The sauce is homemade and you can tell from the first bite. I wish I lived closer to this great little spot. They also have covered outdoor dining as well.

A great place for New York style pizza when visiting the