Gators - Hampton Bays
Menu
Here you will find the menu of Gators in Hampton Bays. At the moment, there are 33 menus and drinks on the menu.
Gators in Hampton Bays, NY, is a renowned American restaurant, proudly boasting an impressive average rating of 4 stars. Whether you're enjoying an intimate dinner for two or celebrating a special occasion with friends, be sure to call ahead at (631) 728-4100 to reserve your table. For those cozy evenings at home, you can easily order your favorite dishes through Uber Eats. Don’t forget to savor a delightful cup of coffee during your visit. If you love what you see on the menu but crave more options, be sure to check out nearby gems like Tony's Fusion Express and Baymen's Deli. Enjoyed your meal? We’d love to hear your thoughts—leave a review!.
Images
Feedback
**Discovering Gators: A Local Gem Worth Revisiting** Gators has emerged as a beloved dining destination for many, celebrated for its mouthwatering burgers and inviting atmosphere. Guests often rave about the exceptional service, particularly from friendly staff like bartender Diane and server Brooke, who enhance the overall experience. Highlights include the junior burger, black bean burger, and deliciously crispy wings. Though some diners faced minor issues—like a change in burger doneness or an unexpected addition to the bill—the consistently praised food quality and generous portion sizes make Gators a go-to choice. With a cozy vibe and outstanding cuisine, it’s a restaurant worth returning to again and again.
For my meal, I chose my favorite dish: escargot, served with three slices of garlic toast. Oh wow, when it arrived, it was time to dig in! The escargot was incredible, and I was thrilled to find that many of the wells contained two snails each. For dinner, we ordered the marinated steak special, which was delicious! The steak was cooked to perfection—medium rare with a beautiful char on the outside. It was mouthwatering. I also loved the seasoning on the mashed potatoes they served alongside! Our waitress was fantastic, and the service overall was excellent. Gators never fails to impress!
I ordered the junior burger, which came with curly fries that looked fantastic, but I preferred sweet potato fries, so I requested a swap. Unfortunately, in the process, my burger went from medium-well to well done. On the bright side, the sweet potato fries were delicious, especially with the Chipotle ranch sauce I had at home. Just to note, this visit took place on a Saturday around noon.
I stopped by this restaurant alone to enjoy a burger and a beer, and I had a fantastic time. The burger was excellent, and the atmosphere was really cozy. Diane, the bartender, was very friendly. I will definitely be back!
It was fantastic. The food is excellent. The restaurant is small, but it’s clean, welcoming, and the service is great.
I have been a devoted customer of Gators since it first opened more than 35 years ago. They provide excellent value and scrumptious food!
Full Menu
This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients
Chicken
Main Courses
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
More information
QR-code link to the menu

This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.3 / 5 (2642 reviews)#9 Pizza in Hampton BaysTaqueria Deli Mi Pueblito
204 E Montauk Hwy, Hampton Bays, United States
★ 4.3 / 5 (3153 reviews)#6 Seafood in Hampton Bays AmericanCanal Cafe
Newtown Road 44, 11946 Hampton Bays, US
★ 4.4 / 5 (16581 reviews)#4 Seafood in Hampton Bays JapaneseCowfish
East Montauk Highway 258, 11946 Hampton Bays, US