Reviews - Maloney's

American, Irish, North American

Reviews summary

Dining at this restaurant offers a blend of delightful cuisine and frustrating service outcomes. While several guests rave about the friendly staff and quality dishes, particularly the Ahi Tuna and fresh salads, others lament frequent closures during advertised hours and disappointing food inconsistencies, such as overcooked steak and poorly executed prime rib. Some experiences highlight exceptional servers, who go above and beyond, while others criticize kitchen management for lacking communication. Overall, this establishment shows potential but must address operational issues to reclaim its once-stellar reputation among loyal patrons. The search for dining satisfaction continues for many.

Overall Total Score
4.4 out of 5
Impressive | 739 reviews

Reviews from various users

Menu

Last update : 14.05.2023

4.2 ★ from 22 reviews
estel-parisian
14.05.2023

My wife chose the prime rib, which was enormous and topped with a rich au jus sauce that added a lot of flavor. The baked potato was decent, but the green beans were lacking in taste and had a muddy texture. We also discovered a dessert option that I hadn't seen on the menu. We decided to share a brownie topped with vanilla ice cream, chocolate syrup, and caramel syrup, which was a delightful end to our meal. Overall, the place was clean, and the staff were friendly, making for a pleasant dining experience.

estel-parisian
14.03.2023

The food was outstanding, the service was top-notch, the prices were fair, and the staff was warm and inviting.

fstark-fern1
14.05.2023

They serve food and drinks. I heard the live music Finally, it is best to have a non-smoking bar/restaurant.

florence-fisher
14.05.2023

Fantastic service! I loved the Philly Cheesesteak soup, and the Reuben Sandwich was wonderful! They also offered a great variety of adult beverages.

florence-fisher
14.03.2023

Fantastic service! I loved the Philly Cheesesteak Soup, and the Reuben sandwich was delicious! They also offered a wonderful selection of adult beverages.

Sirved

Last update : 17.02.2025

4.0 ★ from 84 reviews
robert-dinsmore-1
17.02.2025

Exceptional food and fantastic service! Definitely worth a visit! This was my impression a while ago, but it's changed recently. Over the past month, I've tried to eat there three times, and I won't be going back again! Twice, they were closed during their advertised hours, with a note on the door. The last time, I called at 7:10 just to confirm they'd be open. We were assured they would be operating until 8 PM. When we arrived at 7:40, the open sign was lit, but when we walked in, the waitress curtly told us they weren't serving anymore and then walked away. I let her know this was our last attempt and that we wouldn’t be returning. It’s unfortunate that this rude blonde is ruining what used to be a great place! However, Pen Can provided us with a wonderful meal that night! Green Gables is excellent too, and Blue Stone Pizza is the best!

dawn-mengel
17.02.2025

I traveled over two hours to have lunch with a friend at this restaurant, and we had an amazing experience. Our server, CJ, was fantastic—very friendly and attentive. She even went out of her way to prepare a special chocolate cake and ice cream dessert for my friend's daughter! The chef also helped serve our meals and made sure we were happy with our food. Considering the price point, the quality of the dishes was impressive (I have a background in the food service industry, and two of my family members own restaurants). I was especially impressed with the fresh tossed salad. I will definitely return to this restaurant the next time I'm in the area to meet my friend!

bill-joseph-cat8043
17.02.2025

April made my birthday celebration unforgettable! I haven't visited a bar in years, but her vibrant energy will certainly bring me back again.

mimi-sharo-elephant1
17.02.2025

The food was exceptional, the service was excellent, and the prices were reasonable. The staff was extremely courteous and friendly.

Facebook
4.3 ★ from 21 reviews
Google
4.3 ★ from 271 reviews
Tripadvisor
5.0 ★ from 2 reviews
Restaurantguru
5.0 ★ from 2 reviews
Int Restaurants
4.1 ★ from 337 reviews

FAQ

These Pictures from Maloney's from Hallstead were provided by the community of Menu uploaded. They show the dining room at Maloney's, the interior, the location and of course great Pictures of the fine food from Maloney's.

Good Rated Restaurants near Hallstead