Sheetz - Hagerstown
Sheetz
Menu
A complete overview of all 9 meals and beverages can be found here on the menu of Sheetz from Hagerstown.
Sheetz in Hagerstown, MD, is a popular American eatery, known for its diverse menu and a solid average rating of 3.7 stars. Diners rave about the unique offerings available at all hours, as Sheetz is conveniently open from 12:00 AM to 11:59 PM. To ensure a spot, we recommend calling ahead at (301) 393-8397 to reserve your table. If you're intrigued by the menu but want to explore similar options, consider checking out nearby favorites like Domino's Pizza and Starbucks. Have you dined here before? We invite you to share your experience by leaving a review!.
Images
Feedback
Sheetz’s recent redesign impresses with a fresh, modern interior, but parking challenges persist during busy hours. While daytime service often shines, night shifts reveal issues with order accuracy and communication, particularly with mobile app pickups, leading to delays and cold food. Some customers report frustrating payment mix-ups and missing items, dampening an otherwise vibrant atmosphere. Despite these setbacks, the staff’s dedication and energy, especially during busy periods, remain commendable. Regular visitors appreciate past improvements but urge Sheetz to address consistency and streamline operations to restore full confidence in their late-night service.
Ordered before hand on the mobile app and the food took over 20 minutes to come as I watched people come and go with the orders they placed at the kiosk. Come to find out, my food has been sitting for over 20-30 minutes in a random area getting all nice and cold. This is now the second time this has happened. Communication and getting orders out is something they definitely struggle with.
I frequent this store often, but I've become very frustrated lately with the quality of food. The latest was tonight. I ordered through the app grande tacos, but when I got home and opened the bag all that was in the tacos was refried beans. I wouldn't leave a lousy review on just a one-time thing. This type of thing has been happening way too often now. Where's the attention to detail and quality control? IF I decide to continue to purchase food from Sheetz I will be checking the food before I leave the parking lot.
I typically rate Sheetz five stars, but my experience tonight was very frustrating. I ordered a burger at 9:51 PM for pickup at 10:10 PM. When I arrived and paid for my food, I also bought cigarettes and coffee at 10:12 PM. After waiting for 20 minutes, I approached the register to ask for a refund. To my surprise, an employee claimed I hadn't paid for the food, even though I had already done so. They did process the refund for the burger, and I instructed them to dispose of it—I wouldn’t eat a burger that had been sitting there for so long. I'm really disappointed with the night staff at Sheetz, and I won't be returning for now. Just to clarify, I'm a regular at this location. I adjusted my rating from two stars to three, but only because they have provided better service in the past. I also want to highlight their recent remodel; they did an excellent job reorganizing the interior. However, they didn’t address the chaotic parking lot. When it’s busy, which is often the case, navigating through the lot can be quite challenging.
Menu
Apps & Sides
Boneless Bitez LargeChoose Your Sauce: Habanero Sauce; Buffalo Sauce; Dr. Pepper BBQ; Spicy Asian Sauce; Boom Boom Sauce
$8.7
Burger SliderzDefault Topping: Burger. Default Topping: Slider Bun
$3.3Melts
Carved Turkey MeltDefault Topping: Carved Turkey
$5.8Burgerz
Made To Order BurgerDefault Topping: Burger. Choose Your Bread: Waffle $0.50; Sliced Sourdough; Traditional Bun; Tortilla Wrap; Croissant $0.55. Default Topping: Toasted
$4.4Chicken
Chicken Tender Sub HalfDefault Topping: Chicken Tenders. Choose Your Bread: White Sub Roll; Honey Wheat; Pretzel Roll; Flatbread
$5.3Appz & Sidez
Mto Potato Skinz$5.8
More information
QR-Code for the menu

This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 3.4 / 5 (5623 reviews)Seafood American Burgers Bars BeerTGI Fridays
Garland Groh Boulevard 17840, 21740-1992 Hagerstown, US
"Great menu. Lots to choose from. Service was top notch!"
★ 3.6 / 5 (3175 reviews)#1 Asiatic in Hagerstown VegetarianSakura Japanese Steak House & Sushi Bar
Railway Ln 102, 21740 Hagerstown, US
"Well, this is the hibachi restaurant in Westminster."
★ 4.0 / 5 (4268 reviews)Seafood Meat Steak Beer WineBlack Rock Grill
17301 Valley Mall RoadMD 21740, Hagerstown, United States
"Cool spot check it out Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4"