Brothers Pizza Hagerstown - Hagerstown

The 1 star is for the Delivery being on time. I just moved to the area and was looking for wings. I saw from reviews, they could have something decent and the brucetta didn't have anything bad to say about it either... Regardless of the soggy Ness in the brucetta from being delivery I tasted no balsamic or onions or hardly ... anything. And the wings were the WORST! Might as well go to the grocery store for some soggy mess. To make it worse, half of the ten WERe crunchy [yum] but the honey old bay was bland. Super disappointed. After working a long hard week, I just wanted to have something light and simple. But they made a mess of that....

Love brother's subs and pizza but you guys do not know how to fry french fries! Everytime I order I specifically say burn the fries, I like them fried dark and extra crispy and the fries I get are always half cooked and soggy, will never order them again

I’ve been ordering the same thing about once a month since this place was recommended to me. The cheese pizza fettuccini Alfredo from here were the best I’ve had anywhere! Unfortunately when I ordered yesterday, it seemed like maybe there was less cheese on the pizza than usual or something because it didn’t taste as good. The fettuccini sauce wasn’t as thick or buttery as it typically is. Not sure if there was someone new cooking or maybe it’s usually that way on weekends? I’ll try to order again during the week next month hopefully it will be back to normal because this has been my comfort food I’ll miss it!

Love the 2 slices and soda combo. Reasonably priced and slices are big

Very consistent! I always love to bring my kids once in a while for pizza and every time we come the food is hot and fresh and the service is good. A little loud depending on the time of day but that's how it'll be when there's lots of customers! Absolutely recommend this location.