Marley's Gotham Grill - Hackettstown

#20 - Pizza - Hackettstown, Grill, American

Marley's Gotham Grill

Marley's Gotham Grill
4.0 / 5 (3378 reviews)

Description

Marleys is a must-visit for wing enthusiasts, boasting an impressive selection of over 300 flavors that cater to every palate. Diners rave about the meaty, crispy wings and notable favorites like bang bang explosion and Honey Mustard. While the food generally receives high praise, service has been inconsistent, with some guests experiencing less than friendly waitstaff. The pet-friendly establishment also offers a well-rounded menu, including burgers and salads, alongside a variety of drinks. Overall, Marleys provides a vibrant atmosphere for casual dining, but for a truly enjoyable experience, the staff could benefit from improved training.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Leila

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 3378 reviews
david-l-elephant27
03.11.2023

First time there and had takeout. Wow, some really crispy wings, tried two sauces and both were excellent, Rice ball was also hot and crispy on the outside. Fries and onion rings were way above your average sides. I will be back to try more of the menu, probably eat in next time.

shawns-h-1
03.11.2023

I was in the area and I couldn’t pass up a chance to grab some crazy flavors of wings. The wings were awesome as always. There is so many flavors to choose from but I always have to have atleast one order of the Mac Daddy sauce. Most other stuff on the menu is common bar fare , burgers are also pretty good but wings are a must try with over 300 flavors it’s hard to choose one or even a few.

d-engineer2850
03.11.2023

After hearing so much about the wings I finally had the chance to try it with some friends and although there are over 300 flavors to choose from I was somewhat disappointed by the temperature of the wings. It seems that they are made in advance and kept warm perhaps under a heat lamp? Of the 8 flavors we tried the bang bang explosion, Jim Beam and maple bacon bourbon were the most flavorful that we had.

leila-d-snake8
14.03.2024

Food is always good. They also have healthier choices. Servers are attentive and polite.

antonio-p-farmer6
14.03.2024

The wings are great, but they also have the Best burger! If you come here and get the Gotham or the Joker and you don't think they are the best or one of the top 5 best burgers you've ever had, well you would be wrong.

FAQ

A little farther away is Hackettstown Station NJ Transit-Montclair-Boonton Line, where you can also access the public transportation.

As a visitor, you can use the WiFi of the establishment at no extra cost.

Smoking is prohibited in this eatery.

The joint offers the opportunity to view sporting events on a TV / screen.

You can also pay for your dishes with the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.