Antonio's - Guttenberg

#14 - Pizza - Guttenberg, Casual, Italian
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Antonio's

Antonio's
4.0 / 5 (802 reviews)

Description

In a polarized spectrum of reviews, one restaurant’s reputation seesaws between acclaim and critique. While some patrons rave about favorites like buffalo chicken pizza and zeppoles, others are deeply dissatisfied, citing greasy pizzas, unseasoned garlic bread, and poor service. Instances of cold food and delivery failures are alarming, alongside concerns about food safety. Yet, amidst the discontent, there are glowing testimonials celebrating the thin, crunchy crust and friendly environment, making it a contested but beloved spot for pizza enthusiasts. Mixed experiences suggest that while some find satisfaction, others leave with lingering disappointment. Proceed with caution if you decide to visit.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Reyna

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 802 reviews
reyna-cabrera-1
24.10.2024

Very friendly

franco-f-rabbit8771
24.10.2024

The owner is very friendly Love this place ! Best pizza and pasta in the area

gabriela-garcia-riv-1
24.10.2024

Nice people, I been there a lot, I like their pizzas, my favorites around there, thin and crunchy jummy! Kid-friendliness: There are highchairs for childrens and it's in the corner of the block, so they can see what ever happens in there too.

talauta-talauta
24.10.2024

We are Australian tourist staying in Guttenberg, we tried the cheesy slice the other night and were hooked....BEST Pizza's in West NY!!

celestine-dupree
24.10.2024

Second bad experience at this place so it’s definitely my last. Walked in and the person before me ordered the same 3 cheese slices. They offer a cash discount and we got charged the same even though i paid cash. Okay then take your tip without asking. Walked out the establishment and the pizza was ICE COLD. It barely touched the oven during my visit and it looked like it was probably sitting in the rack for hours before i arrived. I am currently using my own oven to heat the pizza I paid $9 for. This place is half a block from my home and I would walk 10 miles starving before I order from there again.

FAQ

The restaurant offers the opportunity to experience sports on a TV / screen.

The restaurant also accepts credit cards from the common providers as a means of payment.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.