Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about New York Pizza More:
Fantastic gyro! Great presentation, fair price and stacked full of meat flavored perfectly. The Tzatziki sauce was full of flavor. Pita was fresh and lightly grilled so it was nice and warm. The veggies are also fresh. Overall a delicious lunch. I definitely recommend this place and the gyro. View all feedback.
What Ten Cents Boys doesn't like about New York Pizza More:
Nothing out of the ordinary in terms of service. Prices are steep. Order accuracy was off for spending as much as we did. Also confused about two Sales Tax lines. Either way, asked for no onions on both Gyros and one of them had onions. Had a $4 side of fries and there really weren’t that many. The Gyro meat tasted smoky for some reason. View all feedback.
We ordered delivery, a veggie pizza. Quick delivery, very friendly driver and tasted delicious!! Definitely recommend!!Vegetarian options: Veggies tasted fresh, very good!
Thin pizza doesn’t encompass the whole New York Pizza experience. Here the pizza is thin but that’s where the similarity ends. We ordered a cheese, a pepperoni, and a meat lovers. The cheese pizza arrived cold and uncut. The pepperoni was cut, but also cold. The meat lovers was cold as well. Can’t compare the meat lovers to NY pizza so there’s that, but the cheese pizza and the pepperoni were no better than a frozen Red Baron. Ordered those 3 pies, a single order of abysmal cheese sticks, and 4x16 oz cokes (which they didn’t deliver at first). Bill was over a $100 with tip. Do not get delivery here. The food doesn’t hold up well. If you are going to try it, go to the restaurant and eat in…just don’t get the cheese sticks.
The food wasn't bad. The service was friendly at the register, then we were ignored when asking for more marinara sauce. The ceiling is stained everywhere, there are missing tiles. The walls and furniture is dirty and worn out. We won't be back.The good news is it is off the beaten path and not a tourist spot. Most places in Panama City Beach are crowded this time of year.
NOT NYC pizza. Super basic and almost tastes like DiGiorno frozen pizza. Nicks doesn’t deliver so I gave this a try. I’m from NYC and this business name is deceiving. I’m sure they’re nice ppl, it just ain’t NYC pizza. It’s Pizza Grill.
The service was average, nothing particularly impressive. The prices were quite high for what we received. We also had issues with order accuracy, which was disappointing given the amount we spent. I was confused by the two lines for sales tax on the bill. Additionally, I requested no onions on both gyros, but one still came with onions. I ordered a $4 side of fries, but there were hardly any fries included. On top of that, the gyro meat had a smoky flavor that was unexpected.
Full Menu
Soft Drinks
Salads
Calzone
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
More information
QR-code link to the menu
