You Had Me at Pizza - Grimsby

We love you had me at Pizza! We held our son's confirmation dinner there and they were accommodating, and went out of their way to make us comfortable and cook all of that amazing pizza. There isn't a topping I don't like! We absolute are...crazy about the value of their takeout pizza as well.

Our grandson wanted to go out for pizza and we had taken him there before. We decided to order the Family Feast special which included two 12” six slice 2 topping pizzas, 20 wings, garlic bread and Caesar salad. No drinks included. $65 not too...bad. Anyway, the little guy only wanted one item on his pizza. So when we ordered the adult pizza we tried adding his second item onto our pizza. The waitress curtly told us no substitutions. Really...such a simple request..sprinkle the item he doesn’t want onto our pizza. It would of made us happier spending $65, plus cost of drinks and taxes plus tip. Not very flexible. Whenever, this happens at other restaurants it has never been an issue. They just add the item onto the second pizza. We will be recommending other pizza places.

Been there twice. Had pasta the first time snd pizza the second time. Loved both. We had good service, really good food at a good price. Can’t wait to go again. Took friends there the second time and they were happy as well with food,...service and price. Found it by luck. Very glad we did.

The first time I ordered from this restaurant. I have been enjoying kelseys since my last trip, a month ago they were so amazing that I dreamed since then, so I decided to order from here, as it is much too home. take my advice. Do not waste their time or money. wings are super tiny. I ordered hot and for me they tasted like they had no soaking at all. I ordered extra blue cheese because I like a lot of it with my wings, I didn't even open the second because the wing literally had so little meat on them I didn't even have through the first. hopefully, the pizza is better than the wing! I feel robbed $16

Last Thursday, we had the chance to order another pizza from the best local pizzeria in Niagara, You Had Me at Pizza in Grimsby. We have been enjoying their pizzas for many years and always find them delicious. One great deal is that on Thursdays, their 12-inch signature pizzas are only $12.00! All of their ingredients are fresh and locally sourced, with homemade sauces that enhance the flavor of each pizza. The thin, New York-style crust is carefully prepared and allowed to rise for 48 hours, making it a perfect base for their toppings. We recently tried the Tragically Canadian pizza, which was creatively different and absolutely delicious. You Had Me at Pizza comes highly recommended.