Sheetz - Greencastle

#14 - Fast Food - Greencastle, American, Mexican
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Sheetz

Sheetz
3.1 / 5 (179 reviews)

Menu

The restaurant from Greencastle offers 15 different dishes and drinks on the menu at an average price of $4.1.

Sheetz in Greencastle, PA, is a popular American eatery boasting an average rating of 3.8 stars. With convenient hours from 12:00 AM to 11:59 PM, it's the perfect spot to satisfy your cravings at any time of day. To ensure a smooth experience, consider calling ahead to reserve your table at (717) 597-1201. If you're looking for similar dining options, Taco Bell and Burger King are great alternatives. We encourage you to share your dining experience by leaving a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: taz

Images

Sheetz Food Sheetz Food Sheetz Outside Sheetz Inside Sheetz Outside Sheetz Outside Sheetz Outside Sheetz Food

Feedback

★ 3.1 / 5 from 179 reviews

At this bustling convenience store and gas station that also serves food, customer service seems to be a significant concern. While some staff members, like Selena, shine with their patience and politeness, others exhibit a lack of professionalism, leaving guests frustrated. Complaints often go unaddressed, highlighting a need for improvement in employee training and customer interaction. Concerns about health and safety standards, particularly regarding mask enforcement, have also arisen, calling attention to the well-being of both employees and patrons. Despite these issues, the food quality remains a bright spot, offering surprisingly good options for fast food lovers.

doug-riss
07.11.2023

Terrible service Food was expensive waited 20 minutes on it and then it was cold.

lori-hess
07.11.2023

I called and spoke with a person named Tammy, who was rude, impatient, and unhelpful. On the other hand, Selena was extremely polite and helpful—I would give her 5 stars. Customer service should always be the top priority.

andy-a-cactus47
07.11.2023

This is your typical Sheetz gas station. Very clean and great service.

taz-kaz
27.05.2025

I ordered a turkey sandwich and received the most stale inedible bread. I couldn?t eat it. I should have gone to McDonald?s and I don?t eat McDonald?s.

d-p-rabbit26
27.05.2025

I bought an Italian cold cut tonight, and am not happy. Talk about chinsy with the meat. Mostly bread (sub-roll). It wasn't a bad price, but that's not the point. Rather pay more for more meat. I don't recommend here.

  • Pizza

    Five Meat Personal Pizza
    Five Meat Personal Pizza
    $3.0
  • Dairy

    Panera Broccoli Cheddar Soup
    Panera Broccoli Cheddar Soup
    $4.0
  • Grab N Go Food

    Sunnyside Farms Chef Salad
    Sunnyside Farms Chef Salad
    $4.0
  • Burgerz

    Made To Order Burger
    Made To Order Burger

    Choose Your Bread: Waffle $0.50; Sliced Sourdough; Traditional Bun; Tortilla Wrap; Croissant $0.55

    $4.5
  • Apps & Sides

    Burger Sliderz
    Burger Sliderz
    $3.4
  • Chicken

    Chicken Tender Sub Half
    Chicken Tender Sub Half
    $5.5

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.