Reviews
Reviews from various websites
My friend and I love eating at this restaurant! It's our favorite Mexican eatery. He always orders the Carne Asada, and after trying it at several places, he sa...
read moreThis is probably the best steak taco I have ever had. It was so delicious! It brought me back to the beautiful south with its authentic taste and atmosphere. I...
read moreAfter my first visit, this restaurant has made it to my list of Top 5 Mexican restaurants in Wisconsin. The Chili Verde Sauce alone is worth a return trip. I ca...
read moreI love Mexican cuisine and her is fantastic. I had the Enchiladas Banderas. They are one of the few places that are open during the Arctic freezing process. Lov...
read moreDelicious food! Large portions. Comfy and casual atmosphere. Staff is friendly and helpful. Actually open for sit down meal is a plus.
El Pastorcito offers a mixed dining experience, with some customers highlighting rude staff and order mix-ups, while others rave about the delicious food. Issues range from missing items and incorrect orders to long wait times. Despite these setbacks, loyal patrons appreciate the flavorful dishes, generous portions, and reasonable prices. The Carne Asada and steak tacos are particular standouts. The restaurant's authentic taste and inviting atmosphere keep diners coming back for more, earning it a spot on the list of top Mexican restaurants in Wisconsin. Customer service hiccups aside, El Pastorcito remains a must-try for Mexican cuisine enthusiasts.