Rosati's Pizza - Grayslake

#4 - Pizza - Grayslake, #38 - Mexican - Grayslake, Asiatic
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Rosati's Pizza

Rosati's Pizza
2.8 / 5 (120 reviews)

Description

A neighborhood pizzeria with a split reputation: some visitors rave about delicious, kid‑friendly cheese pies, while others report soggy or undercooked thin crusts, sparse toppings, mushy sides and long pickup delays. Accounts of poor handling and lax hygiene have dented trust for some customers, though well‑made pizzas still earn praise. Expect casual, often busy service and inconsistent quality that can vary by visit or location.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Stephanie

Feedback

★ 2.8 / 5 from 120 reviews
stephanie
25.06.2024

I'm not sure if there's new management, but I visited on a busy night (Halloween), placed my order in advance, and was given a pick-up time. I arrived on time, only to have to wait over an hour! The pizza has usually been good, but during my visit, there was an employee who was working on pizzas in the back and then came out to the front to take orders. He was sweating profusely, and his sweat was dripping all over the counter. He also had dirty hands from handling the pizza. I couldn't eat the pizza because I couldn't shake the thought of his sweat being baked into it, especially since he wasn't wearing gloves. Needless to say, I haven't ordered from them since.

house-of-malachor-li
25.06.2024

The Monday XL special half off price is amazing, plus being the very best Rosati's in the area just makes it that much better. Quality is always on point.

dhruvit-patel-bird51
25.06.2024

I went to Rosati's Pizza because of its good reviews. I ordered a slice of cheese pizza. While I was in car, I realized that the pizza was not fresh. I returned the slice, and I hope that Rosati's will be more truthful with its customers in the future.

sebastian-montoya-4
25.06.2024

Never had any problems, and their XL pizza deal on Mondays makes it worth it.

mary-jo-christenson
25.06.2024

Our pizza was overly thin and soggy, and it wasn't properly cooked. All the cheese and toppings slid off each slice. This has happened two times in a row now. Unfortunately, we won't be ordering pizza from here anymore.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.