Nicantoni's Pizza - Gilbert

I ordered a fresh take-and-bake pizza from this restaurant and it smelled amazing in the oven. I appreciated that they brought the pizza out to my car. read more I ordered a fresh take-and-bake pizza from this restaurant and it smelled amazing in the oven. I appreciated that they brought the pizza out to my car.

Wait a bit because they were busy but totally worth it), and a cozy atmosphere. I will definitely be back for more! Highly recommend Nicantoni's for a fantastic... read more Wait a bit because they were busy but totally worth it), and a cozy atmosphere. I will definitely be back for more! Highly recommend Nicantoni's for a fantastic meal.

Nicantonis is the best pizza place in Gilbert, according to me. Both my son and I really enjoy their large pepperoni pizza. It brings back memories of New York-... read more Nicantonis is the best pizza place in Gilbert, according to me. Both my son and I really enjoy their large pepperoni pizza. It brings back memories of New York-style pizza from my childhood.

Consistently high quality. Our favorite pizza in all of Arizona. We were customers of the original Buono's in Mesa and this brings back all our old memories. We... read more Consistently high quality. Our favorite pizza in all of Arizona. We were customers of the original Buono's in Mesa and this brings back all our old memories. We pickup at least once a week but it's also one of our go to spots to sit down with the family as well. Love the staff too!

We really enjoyed this place during our first visit. We sat at the bar and immediately had attentive service. A beautiful beer and wine selection. My cocktail w... read more We really enjoyed this place during our first visit. We sat at the bar and immediately had attentive service. A beautiful beer and wine selection. My cocktail was moderately expensive. My wife thought the wine was a little expensive. The pizza was great. We also had the garlic knots that were among the best we had. Only enough butter and garlic. The Marinara was good, but not great. The house salad was definitely top notch. Overall, we loved it and we will often be back, I think.