Nicantoni's Pizza - Gilbert

#8 - Order Mexican Gilbert, #32 - Order Vegetarian Gilbert, Asiatic
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Reservation
Reservation request for Nicantoni's Pizza.

Nicantoni's Pizza

Nicantoni's Pizza
4.7 / 5 (897 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Nicantoni's Pizza from Gilbert includes 133 dishes. On average the dishes or drinks on the menu cost approximately $7.6. You can view the categories on the menu below.

Nicantoni's has quickly become a favorite local hotspot, renowned for its exceptional food and inviting atmosphere. Diners rave about the mouthwatering calamari, bacon-wrapped jalapeños, and standout pizza, often reminiscing about cherished New York-style slices. Generous portions and reasonable prices enhance the experience, while live music on Fridays adds a vibrant touch to the dining scene. Guests appreciate the attentive service, impressive drink selection, and delectable garlic knots, with many planning to return regularly. Whether you're after a casual bite or a cozy meal with family, Nicantoni's promises a delightful culinary journey worth savoring.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: User

Images

Nicantoni's Pizza Inside Nicantoni's Pizza Inside Nicantoni's Pizza Food Nicantoni's Pizza Food Nicantoni's Pizza Inside

Reservation request for Nicantoni's Pizza

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4.7 / 5 from 897 reviews

Was Anonym at Nicantoni's Pizza a mag?
The food was absolutely delicious! The calamari and jalapeños wrapped in bacon were out of this world. The portion sizes were generous and reasonably priced. This place is a real hidden gem that everyone should check out. The pizza was fantastic as well. Plus, the live music on Fridays adds a wonderful atmosphere to the dining experience. View all feedback.

hegmann-keara
27.08.2020

I ordered a fresh take-and-bake pizza from this restaurant and it smelled amazing in the oven. I appreciated that they brought the pizza out to my car.

helena60-1
27.08.2020

Wait a bit because they were busy but totally worth it), and a cozy atmosphere. I will definitely be back for more! Highly recommend Nicantoni's for a fantastic meal.

chadd-grimes
27.08.2020

Nicantonis is the best pizza place in Gilbert, according to me. Both my son and I really enjoy their large pepperoni pizza. It brings back memories of New York-style pizza from my childhood.

This is a fantastic spot that truly supports local businesses. The outdoor seating was ideal—beautiful and peaceful, creating a delightful atmosphere.

The food was absolutely delicious! The calamari and jalapeños wrapped in bacon were out of this world. The portion sizes were generous and reasonably priced. This place is a real hidden gem that everyone should check out. The pizza was fantastic as well. Plus, the live music on Fridays adds a wonderful atmosphere to the dining experience.

  • And So It Begins...starters

    Sicilian Style Bread
    Sicilian Style Bread
    $2.5
    Wilbur Wings
    Wilbur Wings
    $8.3
    5 Piece Bacon Wrapped Jalapenos
    5 Piece Bacon Wrapped Jalapenos
    $8.8
    5 Piece Wilbur Wings
    5 Piece Wilbur Wings
    $9.0
  • Small Plates

    Chef's Meat And Cheese Board
    Chef's Meat And Cheese Board
    $13.0
  • Hot And Cold Subs

    Veal Parmigiana Ala Nicantoni
    Veal Parmigiana Ala Nicantoni
    $9.8

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.