Gary's Hometown Deli - Geneseo

They really do have the best potato salad you can buy, and the cole slaw is just as good. I've always made my own, because most of what you can buy is pretty bad. Now I just buy it there. Their meats are high quality and sliced to order. The pastrami is delicious, and it's the real deal, beef, baby. No ridiculous turkey pastrami blasphemy happening here! They also have the most amazing dill pickle sandwich slices. Get them and be happy.

Can't make a BLT to order. They don't know how. If the other party wants a Rhuben, put corned beef on the other sandwich with bacon, lettuce and tomato along with mayo on BOTH sides of the sandwich so the person wanting the BLT can take off the corned beef to add to the other persons sandwich. IT'S NOT ROCKET SCIENCE. Also a larger tomato would do nicely instead of me having to add tomato when it comes home. DO NOT ADD CHEESE TO A BLT. I'm sure you charged me for the cheese. I'll have a fish from McDonald's next time without CHEESE!!!!!!!!!

Great local business with excellent salads made in house. Selection if good baked goods and you can get box lunches. Definitely worth a stop!

Locally owned and operated. Great selection of deli meats and salads.

They didn't let me customize my sandwich. Even though the bacon is probably ready-to-eat, they didn't warm it up and cold bacon on a sandwich just tastes weird so I ended up cooking it myself. The pasta salad never disappoints though.