Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What paulbiggs likes about Pizza Supreme:
Pizza Supreme used to be located in Roosevelt Field near the Time Out Arcade. The square pie was always amazing. There is nothing better than a piping hot square slice with that incredible mozzarella on top, that delicious sauce and a nice crisp crust. Brings you back. Pizza Supreme is a gem. View all feedback.
What Anthony Galvez doesn't like about Pizza Supreme:
Ordered a Buffalo slice and a Sicilian slice. The Sicilian was just ok, but the Buffalo slice was not. It had tomato sauce and Buffalo sauce. It tasted very strange. My coworker had a BBQ slice and it was the same. Tomato sauce and BBQ sauce. We both could not finish. View all feedback.
Garlic knots are nasty dont taste like garlic knots if rather throw it away then give to homeless person do better
Been eating here for 40+ years. Best square pizza on long island!
Bland cardboard pizza, go to mama Theresa’s or Napolini on oak is so much better and more filling.Went in here for lunch, stood at the counter and was ignored for several minutes for the guys stood and spoke together laughing and joking behind the
Because my dad works there and I got it for free and the pizza is delicious and everything on the
Ordered a Buffalo slice and a Sicilian slice. The Sicilian was just ok, but the Buffalo slice was not. It had tomato sauce and Buffalo sauce. It tasted very strange. My coworker had a BBQ slice and it was the same. Tomato sauce and BBQ sauce. We both could not finish.
Full Menu
Meat Dishes
Al Forno*
More information
QR-code link to the menu
