Reviews
What Cody Wickersheim likes about Coney Island:
First time ever eating here and I am super impressed with the menu, atmosphere, and staff! Love how you walk in and are automatically transformed into a whole different era and time. Lots of old knick Knacks, comfortable seating, quick service. Lots and lots of history here. I highly recommend the Coney Dog! View all feedback. What Burton Fleisher doesn't like about Coney Island:
A nostalgic restaurant that if you 're in the Galesburg area don 't miss it! Everything about the place is nostalgic from the menu prices to the interior decoration!!Although it 's billed as a New York hot dog“ place, in my opinion it 's not even close to anything NYC, it 's waaaay more like a Detroit Coney.The famous local area loose meat sandwich, aka maidrite which they call a made wrong (LOL is a very good repres... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Felt as if they were disappointed to see a customer come through the door when we arrived ! However the coney dogs were delicious !
Coney dogs are a must have if in Galesburg! prices aren’t too shabby either
It was great food prepared before your eyes. Can see what they put on your hot dog. Owners were pleasant and helpful. Great things to look at while you eat
A nostalgic restaurant that if you 're in the Galesburg area don 't miss it! Everything about the place is nostalgic from the menu prices to the interior decora...
read moreAlways Have loved the owners just feel the food is not authentic like it used to be Seems store bought and not homemade but love the
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more