Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Elisha Rosenbaum likes about Eatali’s Pizza:
Im glad I found this place! Its close to home, clean and delicious. The owner is so nice and welcoming. The pizzas are huge and for a good price, we're excited to come back and try new things! View all feedback.
What Elisha Rosenbaum doesn't like about Eatali’s Pizza:
I spent 60 bucks for 3 deep plate pizzas and there was no deep dish on top. I also asked for extra sauce and hardly got any. It was good but not worth the money. I was expecting more with all the good reviews but it was no better than your average pizza place. Will not buy here again. Disappointed. View all feedback.
This restaurant recently changed ownership and seems to have no idea how to make a proper pizza. Our pizza was cooked unevenly, with burnt crust and raw middle. The wings were also undercooked. They didn't even bother to confirm our order. Normally I don't leave reviews, but they really need to improve their cooking skills. Overall, the pizza was a disappointment.
Well, I really wanted to support a local pizza place, but would have been looking elsewhere. The pizza I ordered was best 2 stars. I ordered the Godfather and paid to add fresh basil. When I got the pizza home, the sun-dried tomatoes were burned to a gun (you should add them directly after the pizza comes from the oven FYI to the owners) not before you cook the pizza. The fresh basil was dried. The sauce, dough and cheese were pretty good. I won't come back. I think you have to hire a consultant who understands pizza.
The pizza at this restaurant is out of this world. The Stromboli, Calzone, Wings, and Cannolis are always fresh and delicious.
Pizza is great, but they suck in fulfilling DoorDash orders. I ordered a Margherita pizza and 2 slices Key Lime Pie. I got a basic cheese pizza and two slices of frozen cheesecake (I think it was cheesecake because it tasted nothing like key lime). Well, the first one has done anyway. I put the other one in the fridge for the next day. The next morning it was Moldy. They obviously gave me something that was frozen too long and then sat in the refrigerator too long after they had been frozen. I don't know, but getting mold is unacceptable.
The handmade pizza at this restaurant is delicious! The owner is incredibly friendly and our pizza arrived promptly. This will definitely be our new favorite spot for pizza!