Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What James Hicks likes about Lost Pizza Co. Indianola:
First time here! There are sooo many places to eat in Florence and Sheffield, college students should have no problem finding a place to eat! Well, not just college kids, my wife and I love to come here and make a big deal about where to eat. Thing is, you can't choose wrong! At least we haven't yet!Chicken alfredo was mucho excellent, ? salad fresh and green, bread sticks, hot and cheezy, how can you go wrong? Nuff... View all feedback.
What William Valentine doesn't like about Lost Pizza Co. Indianola:
We were in the mood for pizza and a beer on a Saturday afternoon. Being a first visit, there was little assistance in seating and ordering (order at the counter, given an order number card, they hand you the beers, and find your table). The lady at the counter didn’t seem all that interested in giving info without being asked even when we told her this was our first visit.We would have liked frosted mugs (we were ins... View all feedback.
We were in the mood for pizza and a beer on a Saturday afternoon. Being a first visit, there was little assistance in seating and ordering (order at the counter, given an order number card, they hand you the beers, and find your table). The lady at the counter didn’t seem all that interested in giving info without being asked even when we told her this was our first visit.We would have liked frosted mugs (we were instructed to go ask the bartender). The bartender was not behind the bar to ask (we later noticed that she was elsewhere socializing).So atmosphere service are 3’s (at the most). The pizza was great and hot. So food gets a 5! We will probably return at some point.
The small pizza is a perfect single serving size for a big guy like me. They also have thin and thick crust options. Lots of varieties to choose from.
First time here! There are sooo many places to eat in Florence and Sheffield, college students should have no problem finding a place to eat! Well, not just college kids, my wife and I love to come here and make a big deal about where to eat. Thing is, you can't choose wrong! At least we haven't yet!Chicken alfredo was mucho excellent, ? salad fresh and green, bread sticks, hot and cheezy, how can you go wrong? Nuff and..
The food is great but the oldest person on the wait staff was maybe 12, which was odd. The only adult employee I saw was an older guy in the back.
This place is always awesome and food is on point every time !!!