Reviews
What User likes about Old Croton Grill:
this was the first disappointing meal I had here and possibly because it was silvester and the kitchen and the waiting staff overwhelmed. the menu was limited and what I could order was not very good. calamari was boiled and tasteless, while the pasta was over boiled and muddy. I want to come back and give them another shot under normal conditions. View all feedback.
What User doesn't like about Old Croton Grill:
the service was terrible. the apps were decent, but the dinners were not on the ground. most dishes came out, could and one of our meal times was never put into the hand, so after the rest of the table was served. the waitress apologised, but no one offered us a drink or discount because of inconvenience. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Food was great. I had a party of 5, and we all enjoyed our food. Our waitress was awesome. The only thing I would request for next time would be to sit a little...
read morePizza and dirty martini...Outstanding! Was a bit noisy with the band but fun all the same.
Excellent eating! great atmosphere, band was great! our server was attentive and very personal.
The service was terrible. the apps were decent, but the dinners were not on the ground. most dishes came out, could and one of our meal times was never put into...
read moreI've been here many times and had no problems with the services or eating.
The food was outstanding! The atmosphere was wonderful, and the band was fantastic! Our server was attentive and very friendly.
The service was terrible. The appetizers were okay, but the main courses were disappointing. Most of our dishes arrived lukewarm, and one of our meals was overl...
read moreI have visited this place numerous times and have never encountered any issues with the service or the food. I will definitely continue to return.
This was the first disappointing meal I’ve had here and possibly because it was New Year’s Eve and the kitchen and wait staff was overwhelmed. The menu was limi...
read more