Olde Hickory - Fenton
Olde Hickory
Description
A longtime local favorite, Olde Hick serves generous, affordably priced comfort food—standout fish and chips, perch, and huge pizzas—in a casual, pub‑style setting. Many praise the consistent portions, friendly regulars' service and good value, while others note spotty or slow service, occasional cold or overcooked dishes, and mixed cleanliness impressions. It’s ideal for relaxed, budget‑minded meals; consider takeout if timing and attentive service are priorities.
Images
Feedback
The food is fantastic, and the service isn't bad either. I've been coming here for years and really enjoy the atmosphere. The people are wonderful, and the live music on the weekends is great!
I did not have a good experience at all. The staff was quite rude, and the restaurant felt old and dirty. There was a terrible smell, and we quickly finished our drinks and left. I wasn't expecting anything fancy since it's more of a dive bar vibe, but it definitely needs some improvements.
The atmosphere was wonderful, the value was fantastic, and the portions were generous! I ordered the perch, while my daughter tried the bluegill. Both dishes were outstanding! Our server, Krissy, was excellent too. I highly recommend this place!
Great steak sandwich and fish fry! We go here without having a reservation and always manage to get a seat. A rare thing these days! Extremely casual. Clean. Food is consistently good.
Best food around hidden gem!!! Tip your awesome bartender waitress Denise!! Great pizza, great perch, great burrito's
Menu
Soup, Salad, And Chili
Italian Specialties
Fish Dishes
Appetizers
Side Dishes
Snacks
Menu PDF
FAQ
More information
QR-Code for the menu
