Paula's - Everettville

This restaurant was a fantastic find. The apps were delicious and the bartender was very personable and professional.

This is very pleasant and friendly dinner spot with a casual feel but with just enough elegance it's a place you'd take your parents to. I had the pasta with salmon special and my husband had the fried cauliflower and we split a salad. Good wine list, and husband enjoyed a strong vodka martini. He actually had a second one, which is always a good sign. Sargasso is a solid place, not cutting edge or anything, but I enjoyed it.

Basically ridiculous prices for terrible food. They want to charge Morton’s fine dining prices but deliver a dirty table, and food that easily seems to be cooked by untrained high schoolers. If you are looking to be charged $54 for a minuscule piece of steak about the size of a tangerine placed on top of literal A1 steak sauce accompanied by overcooked fingerling potatoes that are dry and over seasoned come here. If you are looking to order a “salad“ that consists of sliced almost expiring celery with a few pieces of dry date and some poor quality red sauce advertised as cranberry but having no taste of cranberry, then come here. If you want to sit on tables that are so dirty your arm sticks to it when you take it off the table, then come here. The staff is polite, because this is Morgantown, WV. Everything else is a joke. I could have had better tasting food from McDonalds.

I’ve loved Sargasso for years. All experiences were nearly perfect up till my visit on 5/31. The restaurant was nearly empty (3 tables and one group in the private area). Our meal took a complete hour to arrive after ordering. As a family with 4 kids, this was rough. Everyone was miserably hungry by the time the food arrived. In my group, all seemed to enjoy their food minus mine. The pork chop was simply average. It tasted like shake and bake breading with a fatty piece of meat. I won’t give up on the one bad experience but I’m certainly disappointed.

Pretensious, overpriced, terribly done food. We ordered the sausage ragu, no salad, little bit of bread on the side, couldn't find any sausage, pasta swimming in a greasy, acidic gross excuse for sauce. Had to take several antacid when we got home. We'll never go back. 30 bucks for worse than canned pasta and meat balls.