The Starlight - Eureka

Drinks, Pub, Pizza

The Starlight

The Starlight
4.4 / 5 (103 reviews)

Description

With lively live music and attentive bartenders showcasing daily shakes, rotating drink specials and occasional giveaways, this popular neighborhood spot pairs well-priced cocktails and wine with standout fresh seafood. Generous, cooperative staff create cozy, sociable evenings that fill up quickly on weekend nights, so early arrival is wise. The kitchen delivers flavorful dishes — creamy coleslaw, sweet potato fries and excellent fish — and regulars keep coming back for the warm service and good value.

Last update: 12.07.2026 from: Rachel

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 103 reviews
rachel-poklasny
26.02.2025

This is a fun and friendly spot for a small town. It recently came under new ownership, and the new owner is doing a fantastic job!

simamkele-loli-1
26.02.2025

Best regards, Robert Stella Company line: [hidden number] WhatsApp: +1 (717) 742-0664 Email: [hidden email]

susan-l-jones-savka-2
26.02.2025

Great food, some of the best fresh fish we have ever had. Loved the creamy coleslaw and will try the red cabbage slaw next time around. The sweet potato fries were pretty good and I liked the tartar sauce. Super service. Only one girl was on, Chelsea, but she made sure we had everything we needed. Luckily, we got there fairly early, about 4:30 pm, because it looks like it fills up quickly on a Friday night!

stephanie-ann-novotn
26.02.2025

I absolutely love the atmosphere here! I always have a fantastic time whether I'm sitting at the bar or serving it.

dillon-mayo
03.11.2023

Last week was the first time in this restaurant. But It is absolutely not the last time. We enjoyed the evening a lot with the good service, with the excellent cooking and wine and with the comfortable cost. We will no doubt come back soon.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.