Casey's - Eureka

Breakfast, Lunch, Pizza
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Casey's

Casey's
3.9 / 5 (673 reviews)

Menu

On this Site, you will find the complete menu of Casey's from Eureka. At present there are 9 dishes and beverages available.

At this roadside Casey’s location, reliable pizza, clean gas pumps and a popular rewards program make it a handy stop for commuters and solo diners. Regulars praise friendly counter staff and consistent food quality, while others report uneven service—particularly during evening shifts—occasional inventory shortages (drinks), refusal to customize wraps, confusing fuel-grade labeling, delayed orders and inattentive clerks. Online ordering works but can be slow. Overall: convenient and tasty, but inconsistent customer service and fuel-pump clarity can frustrate patrons.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Linda

Images

Casey's Food Casey's Outside Casey's Logo

Feedback

★ 3.9 / 5 from 673 reviews

Was Ethan Kossover at Casey's a mag?
Like every Casey's location, the gas pumps here are clean and well-maintained. The rewards program is a fantastic feature. Plus, it's conveniently situated with easy access from the road. View all feedback.

What Douglas Stewart dislikes about Casey's:
I usually like this location because of its friendly service, but I've noticed that they frequently run out of drinks. Each time I visit during the evening shift, it seems like the staff is more focused on their phones or chatting than on their tasks. For example, tonight, on August 29, 2022, at 9:15 PM, the cashier was busy chatting, and I had to ask twice whether my payment had been processed because I didn’t see a... View all feedback.

sharlene-delashmit
03.11.2023

Horrible customer service. What is the purpose of selling sandwiches and wraps when you refuse to make them when ordered. I hope this helps others to not waste their time stopping at this location

k-b-ivy7
03.11.2023

Went to Casey's for gas. No where on the pump does it say super or regular, see attached pictures. They both say unleaded. It was raining I did not see the price window on them. One was $2.59 the other $3.04. I found this out after noticing I should of had 8.04 gallons of gas not 7.21 gallons. Why would the prices be different when the sign only advertised one and you can't tell the difference by looking at the pump. Except the tiny freaking price window. I only noticed the price window when I realize I did not have the correct amount of gas. I talked to a store employ she said those are the new lables on them. She could not answer why theres not a sign indicating the difference. I asked for a manager, the store employee called for him. I waited for a bit, the manager never came out of the back. Lesson learned, do not get gas here again.

douglas-stewart-gras
03.11.2023

I usually like this location because of its friendly service, but I've noticed that they frequently run out of drinks. Each time I visit during the evening shift, it seems like the staff is more focused on their phones or chatting than on their tasks. For example, tonight, on August 29, 2022, at 9:15 PM, the cashier was busy chatting, and I had to ask twice whether my payment had been processed because I didn’t see a receipt printed out, and I wasn’t offered one at all.

linda-mcelroy-1
26.02.2025

Just your regular convenience store, clean with helpful staff. They do have freshly made pizza which is very good.

danny-hills
26.02.2025

Great place for donuts Service: Takeaway Meal type: Breakfast Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.