Geno Nottolini's Pizza Catering Company

The pizzas and pastas are fantastic. We especially enjoy the Wednesday pasta special, where you can get a second entree for just a dollar. I give it 4 stars instead of 5 due to the loud music playing in the background. The prices are reasonable, and I always call ahead for pick-up since we never dine in. The place is clean, but there are only about a dozen chairs available.

This review has been downgraded by two stars due to unfulfilled simple yet significant requests. The basic request was for easy cheese and a well-done pizza for flavor. The more important request was for no contact—please leave the delivery at the front door with a note that says "I will see you," so my dog wouldn’t bark. To make matters worse, I paid extra for pepperoni and was left feeling disappointed. I'm trying not to let that impact my overall experience too much, but it’s certainly challenging.

I was really disappointed with the meat sauce. It was overly oily and upset my stomach. For the love of everything, please drain the grease from the meat before adding it to the sauce. The grease floats on top, making it unappetizing to eat.

We got the Wednesday Special buy one pasta get one for 99 cents. We had chicken Alfredo and one was mushrooms and Alfredo. On the chicken alfredo the sauce was watery and there weren't very many noodles. The mushroom Alfredo was good. I feel this placehas been hit or miss when ordering from them. We won't be ordering pasta any time soon from here again

Good chicago pizza joint Sauce is great Pizza crust is cooked to perfection Perfect ratio of ingredients. ONLY NEGATIVE , which can not allow me to rate it 5 stars , IS THE CHEESE !!! It?s almost like processed cheese from a bag. If they could spend theextra money and get some fresh cheese to shred and throw on there I?d buy a pizza or two at least a week