The Eldred Preserve

American, Delivery Services, Fish
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +18455578316
Reservation
Reservation request for The Eldred Preserve.

The Eldred Preserve

The Eldred Preserve
4.0 / 5 (778 reviews)

Menu

Here you will find the menu of The Eldred Preserve in Eldred. At the moment, there are 52 menus and drinks on the menu.

The Eldred Preserve in Eldred, NY is an American restaurant with an average rating of 4.4 stars. Don't wait until it's too late or too busy - call ahead to book your table at (845) 557-8316. If you're looking for similar dining options, consider visiting Corner Piazza or The Homestead Restaurant Lounge. If you enjoyed your meal at The Eldred Preserve, don't forget to leave a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Paul

Images

The Eldred Preserve Food The Eldred Preserve Food The Eldred Preserve Food The Eldred Preserve Food The Eldred Preserve Food The Eldred Preserve Food The Eldred Preserve Drink The Eldred Preserve Inside

Reservation request for The Eldred Preserve

Enquire Reservation Now

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 778 reviews

This restaurant is a beautifully designed venue offering a pleasant atmosphere, exceptional service, and good food options, though experiences may vary widely. While highlights include well-cooked steaks and delightful bread, some dishes have controversial reputations, with reports of dryness or overpowering flavors. The setting and decor receive consistent praise, enhancing the dining experience. Guests have shared memorable occasions here, including New Year's celebrations and birthdays. Although it can be on the pricey side, the combination of ambiance and service keeps patrons returning for more.

gaetano-mauriello
Gaetano 17.02.2024 - 19:36

New Year's Eve. The food was just average at best. Our waitress was very friendly and pleasant, but her service could have been improved significantly.

sandeep-malhotra
Sandeep 17.02.2024 - 19:36

The food at the restaurant was below average. The duck was had, dry and chewy and the sauce was too sweet. The daily special fried cod with everything bagel crusting was terrible and had a bad odour to it and had to be sent back. The replacement miso salmon was better but still overcooked. The bright spots were the ribeye steak that was well cooked and the chocolate desert. Service vas outstanding. Polite, efficient and courteous. The atmosphere and decor were decent. We were seated in a room adjacent to the main seating area which was cold but the staff did raise the temperature a little. Overall a disappointing experience.

localgal
LocalGal 17.02.2024 - 19:36

We visited during a snowstorm and were the only guests who didn't cancel our reservations. Even though we were the only table in the entire restaurant (the adjoining hotel had no guests either), we received a warm welcome. The food and service were outstanding, and we never felt rushed. It was a truly enjoyable experience.

paul
Paul 27.02.2025 - 00:20

Our second time here, awesome food, excellent service

joseph
Joseph 27.02.2025 - 00:20

Enjoyed the entire experience from appetizer thru desserts. Very nice server

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.