Edgartown Seafood

It wasn't what I expected at all, but it turned out to be a wonderful surprise. Edgartown Seafood is primarily a fish market, yet they served some of the freshest soup and lobster rolls I've ever had in my life. It's unfortunate that they weren't busier because anyone not visiting is truly missing out. While the place doesn't have any seating, there's a lovely park just a couple of hundred yards away where we enjoyed our food on the benches. As tourists, this was a fantastic experience, and next time we visit Martha's Vineyard, we'll definitely be coming back.

The fresh seafood here is amazing! The staff is incredibly friendly and very attentive. I make it a point to visit every time I'm on Martha's Vineyard!

This was not what I expected, but it turned out to be a delightful surprise. Edgartown Seafood is primarily a fish market, yet it serves some of the freshest soup and lobster rolls I've ever had. It's unfortunate to see that it's not busier, as those who skip this place are truly missing out. Although there are no tables to sit at, there's a park just a short walk away where we enjoyed our meal on the benches. As tourists, we had a wonderful experience, and I can confidently say that we'll be returning to Edgartown Seafood on our next trip to Martha's Vineyard.

Always delicious with laid back, friendly service. Lobsters cooked to order :

Great island family owns this buisness. They also support and are good the the island commercial fisherman