Atlantic Fish & Chop House - Feedback

We made reservations for a party of 6 online. Upon arrival, we discovered they sat us at two separate tables opposite each other. I kindly asked to have the tab...

WORST RESTAURANT EVER! Worst staff, worst view do not go here!

Came here with a group for lunch on a Wednesday afternoon and were seated at a lovely table on the water. I ordered the mushroom polenta for my main and was dis...

5 stars across the board I'll go as many times as I can

Went for my wife's birthday, the food was excellent, the dessert menu was lacking, and the waiter was arrogant. Was served a moldy and rotting strawberry(mockta...

I had wanted sone escargots and another court, but they were all out....his disappointed that we ended up ordering Clam-Chowder and tomaten bisque suppe. the po...

Comfortable and elegant. the celtics observed at the bar while she had a delicious meal. lobster ravioli was delicious and had a little kick on it!

Totally pretentious and chuck full of a baptism of wanting to be, top crust aspiration pose. if they want to pretend to be someone and act as if they were somet...

Atlantic fish chop house management, you host (one man standing at the host standing at 2:30p 5/29/2022) is a complete lügner! After he had given us an inside,...

Ate here Lunch in May 2022 before high season. Justificably one of the best places in Edgartown. Well worth a visit. Great views across the water and easy parki...

I've been going to the Atlantic for many years and the food has always been delicious. When we came back to dinner this year, we were blown away from our meal....

Family celebration in October! Friendly atmosphere and excellent food and service! Crackling pig dog was tasteful and moist and the slice chocolate mousse cake...

This can be our favorite restaurant on the island, especially if you have a place outside overlooking Edgartown Harbor. Food is always excellent and well prepar...

Food and landscape is the picture perfect! We sat outside, near the docks, for a big scenery when the sun began to sit. If you are looking for COVID safe food,...

Great food, Great ambiance, Great views of the Harbor but just a little bit pricey.

Great location on the water with outdoor tables that sit directly on the dock! The food was very good. We had the Lobster-Arugula salad, the octopus and the...

The food was very good. I wish they had some better descriptors with each article in the menu. You were very fast and nice when you order and get our food!

Actually, I don't get bad reviews. Admittedly, there is low season, so there were no crowds and the service was great. We started with the shells that...