Reviews
What User likes about Petonito's Pastry Cupcake Shoppe:
We ordered my mother's birthday cake from Petonito this year, and they did an amazing job! She requested a chocolate cake with strawberry mousse and whipped cream, decorated with a St. Patrick's Day theme. I was truly impressed with how the cake turned out. Thank you for making her birthday so memorable! While there, I couldn't resist grabbing some zeppole and cannoli as well. The cannoli shells were made in-house an... View all feedback. What User doesn't like about Petonito's Pastry Cupcake Shoppe:
I wouldn't even give them one star, but this is not an option. I always like to give places a second chance. Since Petonito's has been taken over by new owners the pastries have not been the same. Twice now i have gone and i have gotten stale and raw pastries specifically the Sfogliatella and pasticiotti. The cookies also taste different, but not as good for sure.... I'm heading to Lucibello's, it's sad that Mark Pet... View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Petonito 's pastry shoppe is an Italian baked pastry which opens in new haven, connecticut in 1954. it was founded by salvatore petonito. the sohn Italian immig...
read moreSo sad that this bakery really went down the hill! I really hesitated to write this review, but I think that others who love traditional Italian pastries and ca...
read moreI wouldn't even give them one star, but this is not an option. I always like to give places a second chance. Since Petonito's has been taken over by new owners...
read moreWas in Branford, back home visiting family. We live in Metro Atlanta-NO Italian pastry shops to be found. Our old favorite in Branford permanently closed, and I...
read moreThe cannoli are definitely not the same, the shell taste stale and the filling didn't taste fresh either I won't be going back here I will try lucibellos
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreI have been using Petonito?s for years. I haven?t ordered a cake since the new owners purchased. I won?t be ordering a cake again. 1. The sweet girl that waits...
read moreWe ordered my mom?s birthday cake from Petonito?s this year, and they did an absolutely fantastic job! She requested a chocolate cake with strawberry mousse and...
read moreI always knew of this place from my parents because they got their wedding cake here over 25 years ago but I had never been a customer here myself until today t...
read moreI would like to thank Petonito?s for going above and beyond what I think other shops may have not done onMother?s Day. I called for a last minute order for 6 cu...
read moreFrom the moment we met Mark, we knew that Petonito's was the right choice for us. We admired the traditional and family-owned aspect of the business. Mark truly...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreWe ordered my mother's birthday cake from Petonito this year, and they did an amazing job! She requested a chocolate cake with strawberry mousse and whipped cre...
read moreFrom the moment we met Mark at Petonito, we knew it was the right choice. We were impressed by the traditional family business atmosphere and felt well taken ca...
read moreI had always heard about this restaurant from my parents, as they purchased their wedding cake here over 25 years ago. However, I had never been a customer myse...
read moreFriendly bakers, nice customers, delicious lobster dick pastries.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more