O By Kissaki - East Hampton

I was quite disappointed with my experience. The hostess took a phone call while we were waiting, and it took her five minutes to acknowledge us, even though there were no other guests in line. The food was decent but nothing special. Unfortunately, they were out of two of the three sushi pieces I wanted to try. The uni crispy rice was overcooked and featured a minuscule piece of uni that was nearly impossible to taste. While the sushi and pasta were enjoyable, the service left much to be desired. She instructed us to place our entire order at once due to being busy, and while the appetizers arrived within 15 minutes, we had to wait an additional 20 minutes for one of our entrees after receiving the first. For a dinner that totaled $450, I'd expect a more leisurely dining experience rather than feeling rushed through in under an hour.

Our server was sweet and energetic, but unfortunately, she seemed unfamiliar with the menu and couldn’t answer questions about dessert wines. She forgot to bring a knife for my steak, which I later had to swap for a different cut because the overpriced NY strip I ordered was still frozen. I only found this out when everyone else’s meals were already served. She did make an effort to upsell us on drinks and desserts, but that wasn’t enough to redeem the experience. I won’t be returning until I see a year’s worth of positive reviews.

I recently visited this restaurant with my family to celebrate my dad's 93rd birthday. The staff was incredibly hospitable, and the food was delicious. While it wasn't cheap, the prices were comparable to other places in the Hamptons. We will definitely be back!

Not worth it. The restaurant charged a massive deposit, which didn't cover tax or tip. As of this writing, they owe me money. An aggressive reservation strategy considering half the tables were empty when we left. There are far better places in the Hamptons that don't take advantage of you. The food is fine, but not worth the price gouge. Definitely skip this spot.

Subpar experience. They had a pest problem while we were dining indoors. Flies with the big green eyes were hovering around the dining tables and it didn’t help that we were one of the few tables during dinner service. One landed on our cups and just stared at us… a big turn off and not what I expected from an establishment charging $16 for each piece of nigiri. The service was attentive. The dish that turned the night around was the Sandy Futomaki, highly recommend it. I would steer away from the wagyu futomaki and the bolognese, not sure what was trying to be accomplished there. The crispy rice with uni was nothing special.