Denville Seafood Codmothers Cafe

The staff was super friendly, especially the owner and cooking staff. He made us feel right at home and took the time to chat it up with us. We ordered 2 whole trays of fried seafood and my whole family loved it all. Highly recommend

Great seafood, super fresh and clean tasting fish and a very friendly staff. Overall, a wonderful dinner, will definitely try to make it back soon.

The food is always good, however the service seems to be a kind of hit or miss. Also, the fishy smell is very over-powering.. I wonder if a better ventilation system would help?

Came here today with my family. My mom and dad both got pasta dishes, and they looked good. My wife got stuffed shrimp, and she ate one shrimp, and she didn't care for it. Crab meat was bland and too much bread crumbs. I had gotten broiled crab cakes, and it was the same as my wife. To much seasoning was dry, and too much bread crumbs. I did not care for it. Not sure if we will go back.

We were looking for a seafood experience to remind us that we were at the shore or beaches of SC for some great seafood but this delivered much more! Not only was the food fresh, amazing, and so tasty, but the welcome we received from Mary and Michael made the evening full of fun conversations and information about the restaurants' past and present experiences. We walked away with so much more than we expected, and it felt like home we would be back for more yummy oysters, conversations and history lessons. A perfect evening!