Casa D Pizza - Denville

Pizza is amazing, great service, dine in experience is very good. Byob is even better!

First time there last night after a recommendation, I think the wood fired pizza was the best I’ve ever had in almost 70 years. The thin crust was crisp but not burnt, the sauce was exceptional and it had the right amount of cheese. The onions and sausage on my half were excellent. If you like thin crust pizza, i don’t think you can beat it. This is now my default pizza.

We go out to eat several times and week and we’ve been to Casa several times, as we at Denville residents and always want to support local businesses. I would have talked to the owner about our experience tonight but nobody was there. So… We arrived just about 5:45 and immediately ordered a salad, which was delivered within minutes, at which point we ordered a pizza. We had to ask for it after waiting about 40 minutes. After our order was taken, nobody checked on us. There was a girl doing water and busing and two waitresses in addition to our waitress who has disappeared. Nobody checked on us. We didn’t see our original waitress until we had to walk up front and ask again for our pizza. We were told “it will be right out” and when we finally had it delivered by our waitress who we had not seen since she took our order, it was a very luke warm, “sorry for the delay”. How about a reason why a table of two, a family, and a table of 7 all ordered after we did and were done before we got our pie. Tell us that the order was forgotten, or that there was a misunderstanding or too many to go orders….anything! Mistakes happen but there was zero effort to sincerely apologize or try to make it right. The pizza was amazing, as always. I have to laugh at our receipt. “Server: everyone”. Lmao! How about no one?!?

I don’t crave or talk about pizzas too often. It’s almost always the same experience at most places I’ve had it from. But this has gotta be THE BEST. Completely changed my mind and got me hooked on pizzas now and I won’t go anywhere else. Dough is always crispy but not burnt, always the perfect amount of sauce, cheese, and crust. Quality ingredients. I looove this place!!

This is our go to stop for some good quality food and service. Only been twice but everyone is nice and food is great.