Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Denver

Just like Jersey Shore pizza long, hold with 2 hands and yummy. Closest thing to NJ/NY pizza we can find in Denver. We ordered the half Pep/Cheese. 2 slices had very little cheese, ordered thru doordash. Next visit, we will definitely get the same but extra cheese to experiment with topping quantity. Yeah Sully!!!

Been in Colorado now for 2 years and haven’t found a single pizza joint that was even close to good—until now! This is the closest you’ll get to NY/NJ pizza anywhere and in fact, better than some of the pizza back home. It’s definitely pricey but f me, they have no competition. 10/10!

Love the spot, perfectly easy ordering at the walk up window, staff is awesome and friendly, outdoor single seats to grub your slice quick and be on the go quickly. Have been wanting to see this place. Come through and enjoy the place for yourself, you won't be disappointed, 6.75 slice with a can of pop, very happy all the way around, thanks guys!

I came in from out of town and ordered this pepperoni meatball pizza from a hotel 15 min away. Door dash got it to me at a decent time. The pizza tasted great and the slices are HUGE. The regular ranch AND the chipotle ranch taste good also! I will be back the next time I’m in town!

Went to Denver Biscuit for brunch and great thing was how we were able to get pizza too! My daughter order a Slice from Fat Sully’ sans we all were jealous. It smelled amazing just placed on our table! My daughter took a bite and literally said “wow”. Had to take a bite and she was right. Not too greasy, crispy crust and sauce was rich and flavorful. Will definitely be back!