Bennolli's - DELAFIELD

#16 - Pizza - DELAFIELD, #30 - Fast Food - DELAFIELD, Chicken
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Bennolli's

Bennolli's
4.2 / 5 (280 reviews)

Menu

A comprehensive menu of Bennolli's from DELAFIELD featuring all 6 meals and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Bennolli's Pizza in Delafield is the perfect place to satisfy your cravings for delicious Italian food. Our extensive menu features mouth-watering items like savory chicken that will keep you coming back for more. Give us a call at (262) 646 1016 and we'll be ready to serve you.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Sam

Images

Bennolli's Food Bennolli's Food Bennolli's Inside Bennolli's Food Bennolli's Food Bennolli's Food

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 280 reviews

Despite some negative reviews regarding customer service and pricing, Bennolis is a small, family-owned pizza place that seems to have won over some customers with its friendly staff, fresh ingredients, and delicious pizza and breadsticks. While some have had issues with the value of gift cards, cold pizza, and unavailability of certain menu items, others appreciate the quality of the food and the welcoming atmosphere. It may not be the most extraordinary pizza joint in the area, but Bennolis seems to have its loyal fans who enjoy the tasty food at reasonable prices.

kaia-18
12.10.2021

Small place with 3 tables. The workers are helpful and friendly. The kids enjoyed watching her make the pizza. The pizza tasted good and the Parmesan bread sticks were fluffy and delicious. The prices were inline with other non-chain pizza places nearby.

sidney-brekke
06.05.2023

I'm from Chicago while I'd rather have pizza in my hometown, that's the best Wisconsin pizza. The options are excellent, the crust is good, the sauces and toppings are fresh taste. I've been to the pizza pick-up restaurant many times, I've never noticed that the owner's betraying someone. He was always professional.

francois-435
19.09.2023

I have been trying to support this shop because it?s local and family owned. However, while the pizza is good it is not outstanding and you can get same or better taste in the area for a fraction of their price. So that?s problem one, price is much higher. And two, please forget about getting salad here please! For example Greek salad that cost $7.00 is composed of lots of lettuce and few croutons and other identified veggies? Who heard of Greek salad that has lettuce and croutons. Oh well I do hope they make prices more reasonable as at this point there is no reason to really go here as their pizza doesn?t really stand out. Sorry I feel I am being harsh but I am just being realistic.

sam-uttech
14.05.2025

Small place with 3 tables. The workers are helpful and friendly. The kids enjoyed watching them making the pizzas. The pizza tasted good and the parmesan bread sticks were fluffy and delicious. Prices were inline with other non chain pizza placesnearby.

francois-lumeir
14.05.2025

I have been trying to support this shop because it?s local and family owned. However, while the pizza is good it is not outstanding and you can get same or better taste in the area for a fraction of their price. So that?s problem one, price is muchhigher. And two, please forget about getting salad here please! For example Greek salad that cost $7.00 is composed of lots oflettuce and few croutons and other identified veggies? Who heard of Greek salad that has lettuce and croutons. Oh well I do hopethey make prices more reasonable as at this point there is no reason to really go here as their pizza doesn?t really stand out.Sorry I feel I am being harsh but I am just being realistic.

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.