Reviews - Captain's Table

Good food and excellent service. I'll definitely eat here again if/when I'm ever in the area. read more Good food and excellent service. I'll definitely eat here again if/when I'm ever in the area.

Possibly the worst meal I’ve ever had. I ordered the Hot Prime Combo. Prime rib sandwich basically. The prime rib was rubbery and appeared to have been microwav... read more Possibly the worst meal I’ve ever had. I ordered the Hot Prime Combo. Prime rib sandwich basically. The prime rib was rubbery and appeared to have been microwaved. The mashed potatoes and gravy were cold. Ordered the sautéed mushrooms and onions. Got maybe 4 mushrooms and sautéed red onions. That should be stated on the menu. The waitress was competent but the food was horrible. Pretty sure I’ll never be back.

Total hole in the wall joint with really good Walleye specials! Staff was very nice, accommodating friendly but our table service was slow. Clean bathrooms! Whe... read more Total hole in the wall joint with really good Walleye specials! Staff was very nice, accommodating friendly but our table service was slow. Clean bathrooms! Wheelchair accessibility: Entrance and table spacing is ADA compliant

I only had drinks there. Bartender was running around like she was on fire. read more I only had drinks there. Bartender was running around like she was on fire.

The value of the food is about 1/3 of what you will pay for the food. The staff could not have cared less about our table. read more The value of the food is about 1/3 of what you will pay for the food. The staff could not have cared less about our table.

Our server was exceptional, providing invaluable assistance with our menu choices. We opted for the in-season trout along with a variety of other delightful dis... read more Our server was exceptional, providing invaluable assistance with our menu choices. We opted for the in-season trout along with a variety of other delightful dishes. We also ordered martinis, and the owner personally brought them to our table, which was a nice touch. This place is truly a landmark, thanks to its wonderful staff and the beautiful owners who were so friendly and engaging during our visit. Thank you for being such gracious hosts and making my South Dakota experience so memorable. This is a destination worth visiting and driving to!

We travel all the way from Wyoming to dine here. The service and drinks are excellent, and the food is fantastic. I particularly enjoy the salad bar in the spri... read more We travel all the way from Wyoming to dine here. The service and drinks are excellent, and the food is fantastic. I particularly enjoy the salad bar in the spring and autumn.

The prime rib and royal crab legs were fantastic! We received some of the best service and food I've ever experienced. The drinks were great, and the wine list... read more The prime rib and royal crab legs were fantastic! We received some of the best service and food I've ever experienced. The drinks were great, and the wine list was impressive. You can order a glass of any wine on the list. The prices were reasonable, and if you mention where you're staying, you get a free glass of beer or wine with your dinner—what a great deal! This place is definitely better than most in Custer.

We live in the area and are so excited for their salad bar!! I believe the owner makes them and we know first hand that lots of locals cannot wait for fall to p... read more We live in the area and are so excited for their salad bar!! I believe the owner makes them and we know first hand that lots of locals cannot wait for fall to partake of it. We have never had a bad experience at this restaurant and know the Tall waitress . We love her.

Man, the previous reviewer should be glad no one sued them for defamation and slander!!! One needs to be careful about name calling and libel. read more Man, the previous reviewer should be glad no one sued them for defamation and slander!!! One needs to be careful about name calling and libel.

Carla is an exceptional waitress – attentive and welcoming throughout our visit! The infused cinnamon apple and orange liquors were delightful. The fish and chi... read more Carla is an exceptional waitress – attentive and welcoming throughout our visit! The infused cinnamon apple and orange liquors were delightful. The fish and chips were excellent, and the hash brown casserole was also fantastic. Yummy's house made a great ranch dressing as well. Overall, it was a wonderful experience, but I felt the entrees were a bit overpriced considering the portion sizes. Nevertheless, the service and the food were definitely thumbs up!

We came across this restaurant while driving through Custer and decided to give it a try. I ordered the Chicken Oscar, and it was delicious. The waitress was ve... read more We came across this restaurant while driving through Custer and decided to give it a try. I ordered the Chicken Oscar, and it was delicious. The waitress was very friendly, which is something that's rare to find these days. Overall, we really enjoyed our time here.

We had an amazing dinner at this restaurant. My husband had the Philly Cheesesteak sandwich topped with potatoes and gravy, while I ordered the Kollosul? shrimp... read more We had an amazing dinner at this restaurant. My husband had the Philly Cheesesteak sandwich topped with potatoes and gravy, while I ordered the Kollosul? shrimp dinner, which came with a potato and a dinner salad. Everything was delicious! The service was excellent, and the staff was very friendly. I highly recommend this place!

Great “Supper Club” vibe! Very good food, 8oz Prime Rib with loaded baked potatoes and chicken caps Alfredo. Only the complaint was that food came out slowly. C... read more Great “Supper Club” vibe! Very good food, 8oz Prime Rib with loaded baked potatoes and chicken caps Alfredo. Only the complaint was that food came out slowly. Cheap beer and good drinks. Had a great server.