Tin Cup Ice Cream Desserts

Such a cool little spot that fits directly with the butte! I tried the brochure and the motherload. Both were super delicious! The service was great and the owners were so welcoming and friendly! My wife and I can't wait to go back when we visit again!

We were excited to try out the new restaurant in Crested Butte, and it did not disappoint. We visited over Labor Day weekend and had the opportunity to eat there more than once, unfortunately our family could not agree on our favorite pasty! But my personal fav was The Old Timer. Unanimously, we all continue to crave the peaches and cream dessert pasty simply delicious! You won't be disappointed.

My family and I came all the way from Oklahoma to Tin Cup Pasty two days in a row because it was so AMAZING!!! The first go around I had the Mother Load pasty along with the dessert peach pasty. Thought it couldn't get any better until we came back the second day and I tried the Old Timer and the mixed berry dessert pasty. all four are absolutely to die for!! I honestly cant even pick a favorite. I`m adding the pictures I took below!!

Love the food, love the ice cream so glad I went to check it out. It is a must drop place in crested Butte for sure

The most unusual and wonderful flavors you can find anywhere. Very clean. Staff is super nice and accomodating as you (or your spouse) as for samples of everything. Sometimes their OPEN AND CLOSED signs do not match the actual time on your watch and during staffing shortages they have, in the past, sometimes not been open when they said they would be but in the winter of 2022 this did not seem to be an issue. MUST STOP!!