The Peddler - Cresskill

Grill, American, Cheese
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

The Peddler

The Peddler
3.6 / 5 (839 reviews)

Menu

On this site, you will find the complete menu of The Peddler from Cresskill. Currently, there are 247 dishes and drinks available.

Nestled in the heart of the neighborhood, this restaurant showcases a diverse menu that appeals to varying tastes, from delicious pizzas to savory baked scrod. While many patrons praise the friendly service and live music events, others have had disappointing encounters, citing underwhelming food quality, unprofessional staff, and issues with billing accuracy. Despite these inconsistencies, some guests have enjoyed delightful evenings, relishing tasty dishes and warm atmospheres, particularly during special occasions. While the bartending and food temperature have raised concerns, the establishment still holds its charm for those seeking a relaxed dining experience infused with local flavor.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Yongbeom

Images

The Peddler Menu The Peddler Menu The Peddler Food The Peddler Food The Peddler Food The Peddler Food The Peddler Drink The Peddler Drink

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 839 reviews

Was Anonym at The Peddler a mag?
we had last weekend in the peddler a celebration of life for our dad and it was fantastic. Eating, drinks and service were great! Many thanks, steve, peter and dali that they really remember the celebration! View all feedback.

What Anonym dislikes about The Peddler:
Grilled cheese should be melted. Bar tender should not eat at bar. His food looked better than ours. There was a roach on the menu on the bar. Food sucks because everyrhing was broufht out cold. Drinks good. View all feedback.

kathleen-tomkins
02.11.2023

Karen was delightful and the food was delicious we will be back

jerry-squillante-2
02.11.2023

Just love this local place. Every Thursday they have live Jazz and music on the weekends.

jay-cohen-3
02.11.2023

We went there Dec 4 2021, to listen to my friends band County Roads and have dinner. It doesn’t happen often when all 5 of us enjoy our dinner. I had the baked Scrod and it was delicious. One of my Sons had a $35 steak which isn’t a bad price these days and he gave it a . My other Son had a burger and fries and he enjoyed it. My Girlfriend had a chicken sandwich with bacon and she also said she would have it again. My Brother had stuffed shells and a salad. Overall we had an enjoyable night out. The service was ok, no complaints since we weren’t in a hurry. Food came out hot, drink prices were reasonable

yongbeom-park
26.02.2025

A very historic pub in Cresskill.Chicken wings are highly recommended.Servers are kind and attentive.If it were not for the coronavirus, it would be still an ideal place to have a meeting with your close friends.Now it's somewhat cold to eat outsides.They also have spacious parking lots.

b-b-b-horse89
26.02.2025

Tuesday Night Pasta Night

  • Appetizers

    Sliced Tomatoes With Fresh Mozzarella And Topped With A Balsamic Glaze
    Sliced Tomatoes With Fresh Mozzarella And Topped With A Balsamic Glaze
    $13.0
  • Starters

    Grilled Porterhouse Steak Topped With Fried Onions And Bleu Cheese
    Grilled Porterhouse Steak Topped With Fried Onions And Bleu Cheese
    $43.9
    Veal Springhouse
    Veal Springhouse
    $29.7
    Bone In Chicken Scarpariella
    Bone In Chicken Scarpariella
    $29.7
    Fresh Rosemary Crusted Rack Of Lamb
    Fresh Rosemary Crusted Rack Of Lamb
    $43.9
    Grilled Caribbean Catfish
    Grilled Caribbean Catfish
    $30.8

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.