Vinnie's New York Pizzeria - Cottonwood

As a native of New York, I was disappointed. The pane was a bit dry with NO bubble crust on every cake I wanted a little bit. Garlic nodes arrived cold and greasy. My daughter got an empty look when they asked to take her back. If you didn't know better, you'd think it was good. Problem seemed to be too many young children cooking, none of whom probably even had N.Y. Owners need to take a firmer hand in TEACHING staff, how to make pizza

We had pizza in the pane and hot wings. This is a great place for good food. The prices were reasonable and the food was great! They were like any place in these days short staff, but they were super friendly independent. We will definitely come back.

Would be fine stars if it were the way it was when someone insisted to take me there for real NYC pizza, since I used to live there. I talked about this place soooo many times telling people i actually found REAL NYC PIZZA in AZ. What happened??!!! WHY DID YOU CHANGE YOUR RECIPE? No one needs more Arizona pizza, because it's not good. They have a cute bar and sell pizza by the slice but i was so, so disappointed they changed the recipe. A year or two ago, this was the first time i had real deal nyc pizza in ANY state in the west. Now it's just common Arizona level pizza. So sad...

Their pizza is amazing the slices are huge and delicious. I got a slice of the Buffalo chicken and Hawaiian. I was only able to eat 1 and took the other slice home for later. the employees are friendly and helpful. they have so many different options for toppings that it is hard to choose. I will definitely go back once In awhile and eventually hope to try all of the different kinds of pizza they have. I would recommend the Buffalo chicken it was the best pizza I have ever had.

First time visitor. So this is just my opinion on it. We walked in and decided to go with the option of slice pizza. The slices were warmed up, but definitely could have went with fresh. Pizza just doesn't taste the same. If you want fresh. Then order it to go or stay there. But the slice is not really worth it. We also had the boneless wings, which were chunks. All chicken meat, which was nice. We did the garlic parmesan. They were decent. Soaked in a butter sauce. Good for a quick meal, but that's it for now.