Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Carolina Stehr likes about Brooklyn Pie Co:
We visited hoping for some decent chicken wings and ended up having the best lemon pepper wings and pizza we've had in a long time. The young woman at the front was wonderful and very helpful; she even suggested the cheesecake, which was also delicious. It's not often that you find something extraordinary while on vacation, but we certainly did. We will definitely be back. Thank you! View all feedback.
I ordered food several times here and I was not disappointed. The pizza was delicious and even order something that seemed unusual and it was a great victory! I would definitely recommend the Hell’s Kitchen Pizza. We had a slight problem with our order, and it was immediately corrected, no trouble and very professional, so I still give them 5 stars.
The only reason we ordered from here, was due to Padre Pizzeria being closed. I much prefer a cauliflower crust, which they don't offer. The pizza was great. So, they require a mask upon entry, but everyone inside was going from table to restroom and so forth, without.
Update on our post. Dustin the manager contacted us and wanted us to give them another chance. I did change up the order this time to see if we could try different things. Dustin did a good job. Pizza tasted way freaking better this time. Not burnt at all. Everything was cooked well.
I arranged my meal on the table and began taking some pictures—everything looked incredibly appetizing. I appreciated that it even came with cardboard plates and napkins, which is a big plus for hotels. I ordered a pepperoni and pineapple pizza, a pesto pasta, and a starter sampler, which also included some pepper packets and cheese portions. However, this is where I have to deduct a star: they forgot to include my Ranch and Marinara sauces. Aside from that little oversight, everything else was fresh and delicious!
We visited hoping for some decent chicken wings and ended up having the best lemon pepper wings and pizza we've had in a long time. The young woman at the front was wonderful and very helpful; she even suggested the cheesecake, which was also delicious. It's not often that you find something extraordinary while on vacation, but we certainly did. We will definitely be back. Thank you!