Scillonian Club - Feedback

Food, British, Pubs

Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.3 out of 5
Impressive | 1230 reviews

Reviews from various websites

Gastroranking-it

Last update : 25.06.2024

4.2 ★ from 50 reviews
tracy-saunders-rabbi
Tracy 25.06.2024 - 16:30

I didn't try the food at this restaurant, but just one drink was enough for me. I didn't feel very welcomed this time, as it had been much friendlier in the past. They no longer have events like live music or quiz nights, and to be honest, there are better places to go in Hugh Town. Hopefully, it will improve in the future because I've had great experiences there in the past.

andrew-butlin-forest
Andrew 25.06.2024 - 16:30

This restaurant is welcoming and serves delicious food. Thank you to Rich, Ches, Ness, and Ethan.

james-freel-bush20
James 25.06.2024 - 16:30

Every time we visit this place, we are greeted by a lovely and friendly atmosphere. They always have sports on TV that you can watch while enjoying your meal. The Sunday lunch roast is delicious and reasonably priced. It is a private club, but they are welcoming to visitors.

barry-stone-dog960
barry 25.06.2024 - 16:30

Been in here many times over the years. Good beer, friendly staff and i know the owner.

michael-maginn-2
Michael 25.06.2024 - 16:30

Good for a catching up. The carvery is spot on, book early.

In St. Mary's, dining experiences vary dramatically across establishments. While some patrons rave about the exceptional Sunday carvery, boasting generous portions and stunning harbour views for only £10, others lament lukewarm meals and apathetic service when dining at higher-priced venues. Though a few dishes get praise for flavor, the inconsistency in food temperature raises concerns about food safety. The friendly staff add to the charm of several locations, but visitors are advised to book well in advance to ensure a table. Overall, St. Mary's offers potential gems amidst a sea of mediocrity, warranting nuanced exploration.

Tripadvisor

Last update : 05.03.2024

3.9 ★ from 188 reviews
y55fwphilipb
Y55FWphilipb 05.03.2024 - 06:11

We had a disappointing experience at the carvery. Our meals were lukewarm at best, and when we returned them for being cold, they were only microwaved and still not hot. The staff did not seem to care about our concerns. At £15 each, the meal was overpriced for the quality. We will not be coming back.

john-c-library9819
John 05.03.2024 - 06:11

We made a reservation for 8:00pm but arrived 5 minutes late. The restaurant staff were already clearing up and remarked that we were late, but said they would figure something out. We were served leftover beef or turkey with watery, tasteless gravy, dried up stuffing balls, chewy parsnips, and potatoes that were lukewarm. The food should not have been served in that condition. There was no effort to check if we were satisfied, otherwise we would have expressed our disappointment. We paid £35 for two plates of leftovers. Unfortunately, the service at Scillonian Club was not up to standard. Despite being a loyal customer for years, we will not be returning.

dab1000
dAb1000 05.03.2024 - 06:11

Great carvery. Choice of three meats and a nice selection of veg. Good views over harbour . Advisable to book.

shrike86
Shrike86 05.03.2024 - 06:11

This restaurant has a fantastic atmosphere and offers a carvery on Sundays in the afternoon and evening. They have a variety of meat options and also offer a vegetarian choice. The staff, especially Ness and Ches, were very welcoming and friendly. The desserts are delicious, and I particularly enjoyed the Sticky Toffee Pudding.

john-h-bush52
John 05.03.2024 - 06:11

Great pub with WiFi Good service, good beer, free pool and darts and good WiFi. TBH couldn’t ask for much more. Good range of local stuff.

Google

Last update : 25.12.2023

4.7 ★ from 120 reviews
kenneth-morris-lawye
Kenneth 25.12.2023 - 13:44

The bar is fantastic with wonderful decor. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5.

tracy-saunders-3
Tracy 25.12.2023 - 13:44

Price per person: £1–10 Service: 3/5 Atmosphere: 2/5

james-freel
James 25.12.2023 - 13:44

Lovely friendly atmosphere every time we visit this place . Sports on TV available at all times. The Sunday lunch re roast is very good and affordable. It's a private club but visitors are welcomed ...

zoe-soul
Zoe 25.12.2023 - 13:44

No food no views and the beers are expensive Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

peter-ramsbottom
Peter 25.12.2023 - 13:44

Lacking atmosphere.

Facebook
4.6 ★ from 13 reviews
Restaurantguru
4.2 ★ from 287 reviews
Gastroranking-uk
4.3 ★ from 282 reviews
Int Restaurants
4.3 ★ from 290 reviews
Heyrestaurants
2.9 ★ from 406 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near Cornwall,Isles of Scilly