Bagelissimo - Columbus

Italian, Coffee, Cheese
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Bagelissimo

Bagelissimo
4.5 / 5 (5 reviews)

Menu

The restaurant from Columbus offers 33 different menus and drinks on the menu at an average price of $3.3.

Bagelissimo, located in Columbus, NJ, is a highly-rated Italian eatery, acclaimed for its delicious bagels and inviting atmosphere, boasting an impressive average of 4.5 stars. Open this week from 6:00 AM to 3:00 PM, it's the perfect spot to enjoy a hearty breakfast or lunch. To ensure a seamless experience, feel free to call ahead at (609) 298-3300 to check on the restaurant's busyness or to make a reservation. With dine-in options available, Bagelissimo is a must-visit for anyone craving a delightful meal. If you're exploring similar culinary experiences, don't miss out on Smilie's Homemade Ice Cream Shop and Columbus General Store Deli Grill Premium Catering. Have you visited before? We’d love to hear your thoughts - leave a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Brandy

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 5 reviews

Was Larry Hall at Bagelissimo a mag?
While I was stationed at Fort Dix, I stumbled upon this restaurant, and finding it was made easy by Google Maps. There's plenty of parking available, which is a plus. They have an impressive selection of bagels. I ordered an onion bagel topped with salmon lox, tomatoes, onions, and capers. I also tried an onion bagel, an everything bagel, a French toast bagel, and a jalapeño bagel. Their flavored cream cheeses are ou... View all feedback.

What Carol Sano dislikes about Bagelissimo:
This was my first and last visit! The bagels tasted more like plain bread, and the restaurant was rather unclean. I can't help but wonder when it was last cleaned. View all feedback.

chris-m-cactus0
19.10.2023

This is a fantastic bagel shop and lunch spot. It's the closest I've come to a North Jersey or New York-style bagel shop here in South Jersey. I frequently stop by before heading north for work on the NJ Turnpike. The staff is always efficient and friendly. From time to time, they also have some excellent Italian deli products imported from Brooklyn, NY.

hidden-man
19.10.2023

Overall, it was a mediocre experience. The bagels don't compare to the quality you find in NYC or North Jersey. I wouldn't suggest making a special trip just for this place.

gmoen-engineer8849
23.05.2025

Very good bagel shop and lunch spot. It?s the closest thing to a North Jersey/New York bagel shop I have found in South Jersey. I like to stop in before I jump on the NJ Turnpike to head north for work. The staff is always quick and friendly. At times theyalso have some good Italian deli products they bring in from somewhere in Brooklyn NY.

casper-brandy
23.05.2025

First time being here with my wife, We wanted a really good bacon egg and cheese on a bagel and Sausage egg and cheese with fresh hot coffee and definitely we found it here! Wow the food was really good, delicious even we had empanada! ???? the ladyworker speaks Spanish and English and she really gave us a nice and friendly service. They do open at 6:00am

xavier-b-forest05
19.10.2023

My wife and I recently visited Bagelissimo for the first time, eager to try a bacon, egg, and cheese bagel, a sausage, egg, and cheese sandwich, and some fresh hot coffee. We were definitely not let down! The food was exceptional—truly delicious. We also sampled the empanada, which was amazing! The woman who served us was friendly and bilingual in Spanish and English, making our visit even better. They open early at 6:00 AM, which is a great bonus!

Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.