Bagelissimo - Columbus

This bagel shop is a fantastic spot for lunch. It's the closest I've found in South Jersey to the authentic bagel shops of North Jersey and New York. I often st... read more This bagel shop is a fantastic spot for lunch. It's the closest I've found in South Jersey to the authentic bagel shops of North Jersey and New York. I often stop by here before I hit the NJ Turnpike to head north for work. The staff is consistently quick and friendly. Occasionally, they even offer some great Italian deli items brought in from Brooklyn, NY.

I went in to get some bagels and noticed that the employee was cleaning the floor on her hands and knees without wearing gloves. After that, she immediately got... read more I went in to get some bagels and noticed that the employee was cleaning the floor on her hands and knees without wearing gloves. After that, she immediately got up to make my sandwich without washing her hands or putting on gloves. When I mentioned it to her, she just stared at me, as if she didn't understand. Good luck if you decide to eat there.

I randomly stopped at this restaurant while driving back to NYC from my parents' farm. Inside, there was a line of cheerful customers eagerly discussing their o... read more I randomly stopped at this restaurant while driving back to NYC from my parents' farm. Inside, there was a line of cheerful customers eagerly discussing their orders. The line moved quickly, and we received helpful tips from regulars waiting ahead of us. The breakfast sandwiches were amazing, the cheesesteak was fantastic, and even the coffee was excellent! The prices were also very reasonable. This will definitely be our go-to stop on our way back to the city, and I've shared the experience with my family—they all want to visit now too. I gave it 5 stars, but they truly deserve 6! Thank you, Bagelissimo!

While I've definitely had worse bagels, these were quite disappointing. The bagels were chewy and dense. My wife ordered both butter and cream cheese for her ba... read more While I've definitely had worse bagels, these were quite disappointing. The bagels were chewy and dense. My wife ordered both butter and cream cheese for her bagel, but when we got home, we only found butter, even though we were charged for both. The breakfast sandwiches were bland and just not worth the effort of chewing.

This is a good place to stop for a quick lunch! The staff at the front were efficient and answered my questions with a smile. The plain bagel could use some imp... read more This is a good place to stop for a quick lunch! The staff at the front were efficient and answered my questions with a smile. The plain bagel could use some improvement, and the French Toast Bagel was just average. Other than that, it's a typical bagel shop that also offers desserts and pastries.